Undeterred by challenges: The merits of community-led healthcare

Communities that know best what people need - this is the foundation for the Ritshidze project, a new monitoring and accountability initiative of HIV and TB services in high-burden public healthcare facilities in South Africa. Picture: iStock/Gallo Images
Communities that know best what people need - this is the foundation for the Ritshidze project, a new monitoring and accountability initiative of HIV and TB services in high-burden public healthcare facilities in South Africa. Picture: iStock/Gallo Images

When the community leads the way, solutions will be found.

This was the message sent to the new executive director of the Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAids), who visited Shoshanguve last week to see how a new community-led project is working.

The Ritshidze project is a new monitoring and accountability initiative of HIV and TB services in high-burden public healthcare facilities in South Africa.

On Friday the UNAids’ Winnie Byanyima had first-hand experience of how this project works.

She went to Soshanguve, a township north of Pretoria, on Friday for a clinic visit, a town hall engagement with the local community, and the launch of the new civil society clinic monitoring project called Ritshidze.

The visit was one of Byanyima’s first engagements as head of UNAids and came two days ahead of World AIDS Day.

Byanyima (60) hails from Uganda and is an experienced diplomat and activist.

Prior to starting in the UNAids top job in November, she was the executive director of Oxfam International.

Before that she served as director of gender and development at the UN Development Programme.

Her recent appointment at UNAids was widely welcomed among activists, particularly gender activists unhappy with the handling of allegations of sexual harassment at UNAids under her predecessor Michelle Sidibé.

After a visit to a clinic in Soshanguve, Byanyima was impressed with how the community is taking charge of what they need.

“The theme of this report this year is that communities matter; that we must invest in communities and that it is communities that make things happen for their people and that is what I’ve found here.”

She said the community served by this clinic was helping the health professionals to give them what they need.

“Because it is communities who know what they need and it is communities who need to supervise and speak out and demand from duty bearers to deliver. That is important.”

The Ritshidze project is a new community-led monitoring and accountability initiative of HIV and TB services in high burden public healthcare facilities in South Africa.

Byanyima observed that she found a clinic that works despite challenges. She praised healthcare workers for their creativity in handling these challenges.

“[They] turned a toilet into a consulting room; removed the toilet and kept the sink and even though there is no bed here, there’s space for a patient to be examined – so, it is still working.”

She noted that challenges around space and staff shortages result in long queues and waiting times.

“And this is the type of things the community is noting in their monitoring forms. So, this gives me hope that people can speak and be heard.”

She also stressed the importance of communities asserting themselves as rights claimants and making it clear to dutybearers that they are checking on them.

Town hall

After the clinic visit Byanyima heard testimony from local community members who gathered in the Halala community centre hall in Block H in Soshanguve.

These included reports of multiple service delivery failures in public sector clinics and hospitals – the type of issues the newly launched Ritshidze clinic monitoring project wants to change.

People reported long waiting times – sometimes arriving at clinics at 4am in the morning and only leaving 12 hours later.

Some people reported bad attitudes from nurses as well as from security guards and cleaners.

Worse still some said, is the inefficiency and unprofessional conduct from nurses that has compromised their healthcare.

People also spoke about intermittent stock-outs, non-functioning and dirty toilets and emergency services that never arrive on time, if at all.

Senior representatives of the department of health accompanied Byanyima to the clinic but did not attend the community meeting.

A Treatment Action Campaign member who stood up to tell her story, declared how she is living her life positively on treatment but also highlighted the fact that she knows she gets better treatment because she’s a community activist.

Others are not so lucky.

One 35-year-old women’s testimony silenced the hall. As she spoke her voice cracked and her eyes filled with tears.

She said that she is HIV-positive and a single, unemployed mother to two teenagers.

She developed an anal abscess in 2017 that has resulted in two botched operations. Now her life is ruined and she has little hope for her future.

She also has little recourse to hold someone to account.

After the meeting the same woman spoke to Spotlight as Goodness Mbatha, a community mobiliser from the Ritshidze Project translated.

Mbatha met Girly Makhubela in January this year during a door to door campaign.

“I took down her story, but I couldn’t stop thinking about Girly. I live in Mamelodi. It’s far from here but her story stayed in my heart; I couldn’t believe that because of what they have done to her that her life has stopped,” Mbatha said.

“She wants so little – some pads from the hospital, maybe even some gloves so that she can minimise HIV infection risks.”

Mbatha said the woman was diagnosed with HIV in 2006 and she knows that her daughter who washes her and cleans the unhealed sores is at risk of infection.

Living positively

Vionne Visagie, a woman living in Winterveld, also raised her hand to speak in the hall. She said: “I am not HIV-positive but I’m living positively with HIV.”

It brought on claps and cheers of “Yes Girl!” from the audience.

Visagie (32), who lives in Winterveld, also spoke to Spotlight after the dialogue. She said standing up in a hall and giving a positive message is important.

She has felt that way since she was diagnosed with HIV 13 years ago. She found out her status a year after her son was born.

Though he was born HIV-negative, she believes that she contracted HIV from a boyfriend at the time and her son contracted the virus through her breast milk.

“This is the part that is difficult for me. My son developed problems from the HIV and he had something like a stroke so he’s not alright and lives with my granny in Shoshanguve now. Every time I look at him, I think ‘if only’. People don’t understand that pain,” Visagie said.

“What hurts me most is that the neighbours wouldn’t let the other children play with my child and even now he gets sick from pneumonia all the time and I can get a phone call at 2am or 3am from my granny saying she’s at the hospital. Every time I think maybe it is going to be his last day.”

Sibongile Tshabalala, Treatment Action Campaign chairperson, who facilitated the dialogue, said: “People think we are exaggerating when we hear these stories but this is how people living with HIV are being made to lose their dignity … it is difficult to hold back our tears.”

Communities know best

Byanyima pledged solidarity as she addressed the community at the end of the dialogue.

She said her report will focus on communities, in recognition of the fact that community courage and action is what pushes back ineffective governments and weak leadership.

“It’s also communities that know best what people need,” she added.

“I have come here today and I see you standing up and I salute you and I praise you – keep doing what you are doing,” Byanyima said.

She said that patients should not be treated like they had to grovel for decent care from service providers and access to life saving therapies.

Byanyima also had a word for the people who shared their stories of living with HIV/Aids.

“I have seen people crying I have seen your pain – this is a struggle for life but you are the heroes who are speaking out against stigma,” she said.

The project

The event was organised by the Ritshidze project, a new community-led monitoring and accountability initiative of HIV and TB services in high burden public healthcare facilities in South Africa.

The project is a collaboration between the Treatment Action Campaign, Positive Action Campaign (PAC), Positive Women’s Network, the National Association of People Living with HIV and AIDS, and the South African Network of Religious Leaders living with or Affected by HIV and AIDS.

Other partners include Health GAP, amfAR, and Georgetown University’s O’Neill Institute.

* This article first appeared on Spotlight is published by SECTION27 and the TAC but is editorially independent – independence that the editors guard jealously.

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For 14 free days, you can have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today. Thereafter you will be billed R75 per month. You can cancel anytime and if you cancel within 14 days you won't be billed. 
Subscribe to News24


Read the digital editions of City Press here.
Read now
Voting Booth
According to a letter Health Minister Joe Phaahla sent to MECs, the country is ready to get rid of masks in public as a health protocol. Is it time to go maskless?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
About time
64% - 96 votes
36% - 53 votes