Phalatse tells court she is 'entitled' to be mayor

play article
Subscribers can listen to this article
Mpho Phalatse wants the court to reinstate her in her position as executive mayor of Johannesburg. Photo: Melinda Stuurman
Mpho Phalatse wants the court to reinstate her in her position as executive mayor of Johannesburg. Photo: Melinda Stuurman


Axed City of Johannesburg mayor Mpho Phalatse has told the Johannesburg High Court that she is “entitled” to be the mayor of the city and wants the court to set aside the decision to remove her and declare her as the rightful mayor.

Phalatse filed urgent court papers on Tuesday following her ousting through a motion of no confidence at a council meeting on Friday. It was at the same meeting where the ANC’s Dada Morero was elected as the new mayor.

Joburg executive mayor Dada Morero signing the oat
Johannesburg mayor Sello Dada Morero signs the oath of office with Regional Court President Modibedi Djaje on Saturday. Phalatse says Morero is an unlawfully elected mayor. Photo: Alex Patrick/ News24

Phalatse wants the court to also rule that Morero’s appointment as the mayor is unlawful and declare all decisions he will take as unconstitutional, unlawful, and invalid.

Last Friday, Phalatse attempted to interdict the extraordinary council meeting, saying that it was illegal. She failed as the court threw out the matter. In the end, the motion of no confidence against her passed with 139 votes.

In the new application, Phalatse wrote in her affidavit that she was “unlawfully removed from my position as executive mayor”.

I am lawfully entitled to be the executive mayor today. I am lawfully entitled to be the executive mayor every day until my term ends, or I am lawfully removed at a lawfully convened meeting. My rights, the DA’s rights, and the citizens of Johannesburg’s rights are violated every day that I am unlawfully excluded from my office.

The Speaker of the City of Johannesburg, Colleen Makhubele, and new mayor Morero are cited as respondents in the application.

Colleen Makhubele has been cited in the court papers and Phalatse accuses her of having ulterior motives for allowing for an unlawful meeting to oust her to sit. Photo: Christopher Moagi

In the affidavit, Phalatse says if she is not reinstated in the position, the City of Johannesburg “will be governed by an unlawfully elected executive mayor”.

I am currently unable to exercise the powers and duties of the executive mayor because I was unlawfully removed. That is a serious, ongoing constitutional harm that must be remedied as soon as possible.

Phalatse has accused Makhubele of having “ulterior motives” for calling the council meeting that eventually removed her as mayor, and that she has done so for her political interests. She argued that Makhubele “unlawfully convened” the meeting just a day after she was elected as Speaker, following the removal of Vasco da Gama – also through a motion of no confidence.

“The decision is also unlawful because it was taken for an ulterior purpose. The only possible explanation for scheduling the meeting on September 30 2022 was for the Speaker to achieve some political advantage for herself and her political allies. I assume that there was a concern that, if they delayed the vote on the motion of no confidence, they may not have had sufficient votes for it to pass,” read the affidavit.

READ: How DA lost power in City of Johannesburg

She said while Makhubele  had the power to call the extraordinary meeting if the meeting was going to include a motion of no confidence in the executive mayor, she was required to afford councillors reasonable notice of the meeting. But, the councillors only received 16 hours’ notice, which she said was “not reasonable” especially because the motion was pending for weeks.

The affidavit added: 

The Speaker was also not permitted to act for an ulterior purpose. She had to call the meeting and schedule the motion of no confidence in the interests of the city. Yet, it is plain that she acted with such extreme haste solely to advance her own political interests.

The former mayor also argued that the decision to place the motion of no confidence on the agenda of the meeting had to be taken by the city’s programming committee and that Makhubele called an urgent programming committee on Thursday wanting to place the motion of no confidence on the agenda.

“But the programming committee was not quorate when the decision to place the motion of no confidence on the agenda was taken. There needed to be at least seven members for a quorum, yet, only six were present,” read the affidavit.

“The Speaker acted as if there was a lawful decision. Again, the only explanation for her patently unlawful conduct is that she acted for an ulterior and impermissible purpose.”

READ: New Joburg mayor Morero promises to fix the finances of the city

Phalatse says it is “absurd” that a meeting has been called and its “sole purpose” is to debate her motion of no confidence. She said the programming committee had not met to decide whether the motion should be placed on the council’s agenda for the meeting.

“If it [programming committee] had been quorate and decided not to place the motion on the agenda, presumably, the council meeting would have been cancelled. This again demonstrates the undue haste with which Cllr Makhubele acted.”

Phalatse also wants the court to set aside the decision by Makhubele to call the extraordinary council meeting.

She says the election of Morero as mayor is unlawful and should be set aside because there was no lawful vacancy.

“The election of Morero was unlawful for the simple reason that there was no lawful vacancy. The decision to remove me as executive mayor was illegal, and therefore there was no vacancy for Councillor Morero to fill,” adds Phalatse in the affidavit.  

In a statement, which Phalatse released on Twitter on Tuesday announcing that she had gone to court, she said the DA would not “stand by while the ANC and its allies use corrupt means to grab power”.

“The people of the city voted out the ANC for a better alternative and the DA will fight until the bitter end to ensure that their mandate is served,” reads the statement.

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For 14 free days, you can have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today. Thereafter you will be billed R75 per month. You can cancel anytime and if you cancel within 14 days you won't be billed. 
Subscribe to News24
2022 Fifa Qatar World Cup
Latest issue
Latest issue
All the news from City Press in PDF form.
Read now
Voting Booth
As the country marked Fraud Awareness Week from November 13 to 19 ahead of Black Friday, the Southern African Fraud Prevention Service has warned people about the risk of fraud on social media. What measures have you taken against fraud if you'll shop online?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Nothing, I will shop in-store
56% - 41 votes
I have done my homework and will shop on trusted sites
36% - 26 votes
Not much. I'll get the best deals online and hope for the best
8% - 6 votes