CAPE TOWN Sprinkles early. More sun than clouds. Cool.

7 day
  • Thursday 16-24°c Sunny. Mild. Sunny. Mild.
    Friday 16-23°c Sunny. Mild. Sunny. Mild.
    Saturday 16-19°c More sun than clouds. Cool. More sun than clouds. Cool.
    Sunday 15-19°c Mostly sunny. Cool. Mostly sunny. Cool.
    Monday 14-20°c Sunny. Cool. Sunny. Cool.
    Tuesday 15-21°c Sunny. Cool. Sunny. Cool.
More News

Election data 'trickery' hides ANC weakness

2014-06-02 09:06

Cape Town - New research suggests that “mathematical trickery” has disguised weaknesses in the ANC’s election victory.

Gwede Mantashe, the party’s general-secretary, said the ANC’s win was “rock solid”, after receiving 62% of the votes.

Indeed, at first glance the ANC may appear very stable, but separate research by Dr Collette Shulz-Herzenberg, post-doctoral fellow at the University and Cape Town, and by Jonathan Faull, elections consultant at the Institute for Security Studies (ISS), both show that the party cannot afford to be complacent.

Losses ‘obscured’

Shulz-Herzenberg points out that a steady decrease in the election participation since 1994 continued into the 2014 election and “actually obscures significant losses” for the ANC.

According to official figures from the Electoral Commission of South Africa (IEC), 81% of the Voting Age Population (VAP) registered to vote this year – that is 25.3m of a potential 31.4m voters.

But the IEC’s figures are based on the 2011 population census. If you take latest census estimates from 2013, the VAP has actually grown to 32.7m.

This means that actually 78% of the VAP registered this year, Shulz-Herzenberg said, and that almost 8m people did not register, a figure far higher than the 6m put forward by the IEC.

What’s more, if you look at the voting turnout as a proportion of VAP – a measure more commonly used by other countries than straightforward turnout numbers - it has dropped from 86% in 1994, to 57% this year.

‘Expect to see desperation’

For Shulz-Herzenberg then, the apparent steady success of the ANC ignores the rise in the VAP, allowing the ANC to claim a much larger victory thanks to “mathematical trickery with the voting turnout”.

A spokesperson for the IEC said it used the 2011 census data as the official available data when voter registration targets were generated before the election. She added: “The Commission is thus, satisfied that the Census 2011 data as released in 2012, was an acceptable measure on which it could place reliance on its VAP calculation.”

Yet for Shulz-Herzenberg, politicians cannot afford to ignore the more up-to-date 2013 consensus estimates.

She said: “We would expect to see perhaps even a little bit of desperation as politicians pay attention to the data”.

Big gains ‘are not so’

Faull also argues that the ANC’s success is not as solid as it may appear. His research, which is separate to Shulz-Herzenberg’s, looks at the increase in the number of people that registered to vote between 2009 and 2014.

This year, the ANC lost 213 827 votes or 1.84% of the number of votes it won in 2009. “That’s no train smash by any account,” he said.

However, accounting for the new voters added on the electoral role between 2009 and 2014, the ANC actually suffered a real loss of 10.41%, he said.

Critically for the ANC, the vast majority of the newly registered voters are concentrated in Gauteng and KwaZulu-Natal – the two provinces that the ANC receives almost half of its votes from. Together these provinces accounted for 44% of all ANC votes in 2014.

“So what appear to be big gains (nationwide) are not so,” said Faull.

Support ‘running dry’

This year, 370 851 of the newly registered electorate voted for the ANC – and just under 75% of them came from KZN.

If you look across the other regions, the ANC actually “haemorrhaged on turnout”, Faull said.

The ANC cannot rely on the ongoing support of KZN, because support there is “running dry”, he added.

In 2009 there was an astronomical rise of 93.54% in the rural vote for the ANC in KZN. In 2014 there was a growth of 18%.

The rise directly correlates with President Jacob Zuma's ascension in the party and it has “disguised problems elsewhere for the party”, Faull argues - because over the same period, the ANC has lost ground everywhere else.

The party’s majority was the smallest it has achieved since 1994, while support for the Democratic Alliance has grown from 2% to 22% in the past 20 years.

Competition strengthening

Faull said it was interesting that the DA clearly took some of the ANC’s provincial votes – noting that the party will be “salivating” at the prospect of winning some ground outside the Western Cape in the local government elections of 2016.

Shulz-Herzenberg also noted a decrease in the turnout in provinces – where there are large rural populations.

She said that for the first time in rural areas, disillusioned voters appear to be staying at home, succumbing to a “What’s the point syndrome”.

Meanwhile, urban areas are experiencing a growth in the discerning voter, where people are more exposed to political competition through the media. Shulz-Herzenberg said: “Political competition seems to be strengthening, perhaps only in urban metropolis.”

The DA, for example, is gaining some traction in African cultures – claiming to have won 20% of black South African votes.

Speaking at the ISS seminar presenting the research, Nic Borain, independent political analyst, said the ANC will be conscious of this data.

“They will have their own strategist grinding through this data,” he said. “We are not dealing with a static political ecology here. I imagine the ANC’s going to do some serious introspection now.”

Though he added: “I’d counter that with saying: though you wouldn’t think it looking at the Cabinet.”

Borain said he was very upbeat about this year’s election results. “It was a perfect result,” he said, “because it set up a really good contest for 2016.”

Rural future for the ANC?

Faull argues that the turnout dynamics for the local government elections in 2016 favour the DA – because local government issues are usually felt in urban areas where the DA does better – for example, residents will care about traffic lights, rubbish collection and service delivery issues.

In rural areas, local government measures have less of an effect than in urban areas – many rural concerns are controlled at a national level – for example, the provision of electricity.

Faull said: “If you live in an Eastern Cape homestead, electricity is a revolutionary occurrence. You change someone’s life."

He added: “The ANC has been able to deliver more effectively in rural areas than in urban.”

Equally, the impact of government social grants for example will be felt keenly in rural areas – where the money goes further and could be the primary source of income.

Looking ahead, Shulz-Herzenberg said she expects to see a “competitive election” in 2016 – particularly in urban areas.

But this shift in urban and rural voting now poses the question, she said, of whether the ANC will in the future be forced to rely on the rural vote – which appears to be shrinking.


Read more on: da  |  anc  |  iss  |  elections 2014  |  politics

More In This Category
IEC announces by-election date

The IEC has announced a date for municipal ward by-elections.

ANC Limpopo urges party to rebuild, dismisses early conference talk

The ANC in Limpopo has vowed to reform itself and has urged branches to focus on rebuilding instead of holding an early special conference or consultative conference.

3 more arrests for slain DA councillor, partner

Three more people have appeared in court in connection with the murders of DA councillor Johannes Baatjies and his business partner, the Northern Cape Hawks have said.

ANC 'colluding' MEC in hung councils hits back at IFP

KwaZulu-Natal Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs MEC Nomusa Dube-Ncube has hit back at the Inkatha Freedom Party which has accused her of working with the ANC to stall processes in hung municipalities.

Read News24’s Comments Policy publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.
News24 |   OLX  |  PROPERTY24  |  CAREERS24  |  SPREE  |  AUTOTRADER  |