Matjila: There will always be bad investments

Former PIC CEO Dan Matjila. (Photo: File, Gallo Images)
Former PIC CEO Dan Matjila. (Photo: File, Gallo Images)

There won't always be good investment decisions, former PIC boss Dan Matjila has said.

Matjila made his eighth appearance before the commission of inquiry into the continent's largest asset manager on Monday. The commission, led by Judge Lex Mpati, is investigating allegations of wrongdoing at the PIC, which manages R2trn in state funds.

Before the lunch break Matjila discussed the PIC's investments in Daybreak farms and Erin Energy.

The PIC managed to improve circumstances at Daybreak Farm by making leadership changes and addressing governance challenges. However, the Erin Energy investment at the outset was doomed, as operational challenges were exacerbated by the falling oil price, the commission heard.

Speaking specifically about the failure of Erin Energy, which eventually filed for bankruptcy in 2018, Matjila said: "You cannot get everything right in investments. There will always be bad ones, as long as you learn from bad ones so that you do not repeat them again. There will be new bad ones for some other reasons - that's investment."

Matjila said that due to having a diversified portfolio, its clients – notably the Government Employees Pension Fund (GEPF) – can withstand losses.

Assistant commissioner Emmanuel Lediga asked Matjila if he thought Erin Energy would have survived if the oil price had remained at $100 per barrel. Matjila responded that it would have helped the company, but that there were other technical deficiencies that had to be addressed.

'Not a great investment'

The GEPF was the main client in the Erin Energy investment. Matjila said GEPF CEO Abel Sithole felt it was a "terrible investment" given negative media reports about it. Matjila agreed that Erin energy was "not a great" investment.

The PIC ultimately lost around $333m on the Erin Energy investment – $270m in the initial investment and an additional $67m it had to pay on Erin Energy's behalf to the guarantor of a $100m loan from Mauritius Commercial Bank, the inquiry heard.

Matjila said this loss was just a fraction of the percentage of the portfolio, but it did not mean the loss was "insignificant". Matjila said it was important to consider what went wrong with Erin Energy for the PIC to tighten processes in other, future transactions.

Given the money the PIC made out of "good decisions", Matjila said the losses in the Erin Energy transaction had been dwarfed.

The afternoon will see Matjila giving evidence on the PIC's investment in Ecobank. Follow the live update here.

ZAR/USD
16.83
(+0.36)
ZAR/GBP
21.23
(+0.57)
ZAR/EUR
19.00
(+0.99)
ZAR/AUD
11.72
(+0.85)
ZAR/JPY
0.16
(+0.45)
Gold
1802.68
(-0.29)
Silver
18.64
(-0.18)
Platinum
835.00
(-1.41)
Brent Crude
43.32
(+0.49)
Palladium
1939.00
(+1.81)
All Share
55787.90
(-0.15)
Top 40
51536.91
(-0.04)
Financial 15
10339.64
(+0.63)
Industrial 25
77428.31
(-0.10)
Resource 10
52587.29
(-0.39)
All JSE data delayed by at least 15 minutes morningstar logo
Company Snapshot
Voting Booth
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Results
I'm not really directly affected
18% - 1874 votes
I am taking a hit, but should be able to recover in the next year
23% - 2457 votes
My finances have been devastated
34% - 3653 votes
It's still too early to know what the full effect will be
25% - 2629 votes
Vote