Cape Town - Steinhoff International Holdings [JSE:SHF] said it won’t raise its offer for French electronics retailer Darty, handing victory to Groupe Fnac and marking its second retreat from a takeover battle in as many months.
Steinhoff’s offer of 160 pence a share in cash is final and won’t be increased, the South African company said in a statement Wednesday. Fnac raised its offer to 170p a share earlier this week and said Tuesday it now speaks for 51.8% of Darty shares.
“Steinhoff’s pursuit for retail consolidation looks like it will take a pause for breath,” Exane BNP Paribas analyst Graham Renwick said in a note.
“While we believe the Darty deal had strategic merits and would have created value for Steinhoff below 160p, their decision to walk away reflects strong capital discipline.”
Steinhoff, led by CEO Markus Jooste and billionaire Christo Wiese, has now backed out of two retail auctions this year. In March, it ditched its pursuit of Britain’s Home Retail Group, allowing J Sainsbury to win the owner of the Argos general-merchandise chain. The dual retreats complicate Steinhoff’s ambition to expand in Europe and challenge the likes of Sweden’s Ikea.
Fnac rose 0.8 to 54.69 euros at 10:21 in Paris. Darty fell 0.3% to 168.25p, while Steinhoff rose 1.1% in Frankfurt.
Fnac’s tussle with Steinhoff bore the hallmarks of a cattle auction, with each side increasing their offers several times, sometimes within minutes of each other. Fnac’s latest offer values Darty at $1.3bn and includes a partial share alternative of 1 share for every 25 Darty shares.
The French retailer may have needed the deal more than Steinhoff as it has fewer alternatives for consolidation.
“Our independent board and management had a clear valuation in mind for the standalone Darty business,” Alexander Nodale, chief executive officer of Steinhoff’s Conforama unit, said in the statement. At a higher price “it would no longer create sufficient value for Steinhoff shareholders, employees and other stakeholders.”
By combining, the retailers would get cost savings and additional sales of at least $147m annually, Fnac has said.
The auction began last year when Fnac made a proposal that Darty rejected as being too low. It came back with a bid of 101p a share, and got Darty’s board to agree at 116p. Steinhoff crashed the party in March with an offer at 125p a share.