Treasury hunts fraud worth R233bn in spending

Kenneth Brown, the state’s chief procurement officer. (Elizabeth Sejake, City Press)
Kenneth Brown, the state’s chief procurement officer. (Elizabeth Sejake, City Press)

Johannesburg - It’s South Africa’s equivalent to the proverbial $640 Pentagon toilet seat - a paper binding machine that the government buys from its suppliers for almost R28 000, about 13 times what it costs in a store.

Kenneth Brown, the nation’s 54-year-old chief procurement officer, cited the binding machine as an example of the massive waste that means as much as 40% of the government’s R600bn budget for goods and services is being consumed by inflated prices from suppliers, and fraud.

“It means without adding a cent, the government can increase its output by 30% to 40%,” he said in an interview in Pretoria. “We could be building more roads, more schools without even adding more money to the current budget.”

Since the office was set up in 2013, Brown and his team of 93 have led a Treasury drive to contain spending and renegotiate business deals that’s taken on new urgency as South Africa faces a possible credit-rating downgrade to junk.

Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan has pledged to stick to a spending cap, under pressure from the rating companies to keep debt under control and bring down a budget deficit that’s been above 3% of gross domestic product since 2009.

Inflating prices

A major problem is fraud, including collusion between business people and government officials to inflate prices, according to Brown.

“That is where the real leakage in the system actually is,” he said. “People can order things they don’t need, and they can take them home.”

The cost-cutting drive has pitted the Treasury against other government departments. Last month the Treasury said it rejected a request from Home Affairs Minister Malusi Gigaba for his staff to fly in business class seats and it turned down appeals from state power utility Eskom for company credit cards.

Brown has drawn criticism from politicians who are unhappy with his investigations into procurement, said Ralph Mathekga, a political analyst at Mapungubwe Institute of Strategic Reflection.

“There are a lot of ANC or ANC-aligned politicians who say Kenneth Brown’s office and the whole Treasury has too much power to the point they can frustrate political decisions,” he said by phone. “It appears their work has become a nuisance to the ANC. It looks like the party is becoming indifferent towards anti-corruption.”

Smear campaign

Controversial former cabinet spokesperson Mzwanele Manyi told the SABC this month that he sent police a dossier he received detailing large sums of money deposited into Brown’s account.

Treasury will institute a process to determine the truth or not of these allegations and has written to Manyi and his foundation as well as to the head of the Hawks to get the purported dossier that  Manyi claims supports these allegations.

FULL STORY: Treasury to probe chief procurement officer claims

The Treasury responded in an e-mailed statement on Wednesday, saying it hoped the allegations weren’t part of a smear campaign against it and Brown, “who has a longstanding record of serving the public service with great dedication.”

The ANC backs institutions and officials who are fighting corruption, said the party’s spokesperson, Zizi Kodwa.

Brown said the government plans to save as much as R25bn a year by modernising its supply chain.

The office has helped negotiate new contracts for the 20 000 to 30 000 cars it buys a year, getting state departments as much as 30% in discounts. It’s also concluded contracts, including a deal with Vodacom, which provides mobile-phone and data deals to about 400 000 of the state’s 2.2 million employees.

So far the procurement office has stopped 9 000 civil servants using companies they own to try to do business with the government, according to Schalk Human, a chief director in the procurement office. That was the result of the unit putting together a “central supplier database” where 325 000 companies were listed, and owners were verified through an automated system.

Corrupt practices

Gordhan says corrupt practices invariably follow in the wake of the government’s effort to transform the economy to stem the legacy of white-minority rule that ended in 1994 and build black-owned businesses.

“The flip side of this transformation, the rotten product in the gift wrap, is what is called rent-seeking,” Gordhan said in a speech in Johannesburg last month.

“It means every time I want to do something, I say it is part of transformation. But in the meantime, it means giving contracts to my pals in closets.”

Read Fin24's top stories trending on Twitter:

Brent Crude
All Share
Top 40
Financial 15
Industrial 25
Resource 10
All JSE data delayed by at least 15 minutes morningstar logo
Company Snapshot
Voting Booth
Do you think it was a good idea for the government to approach the IMF for a $4.3 billion loan to fight Covid-19?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Yes. We need the money.
11% - 926 votes
It depends on how the funds are used.
74% - 6216 votes
No. We should have gotten the loan elsewhere.
15% - 1278 votes