China stock rout may worsen, analysts warn no end in sight

Chinese stocks sunk into a bear market on Tuesday, and analysts expect losses to deepen as concern over China’s economy, yuan weakness and a trade feud with the US continue to rattle investors.

The Shanghai Composite Index closed at 2 844.51 points, 20% below a January high, denoting a bear market. A Hang Seng measure of Chinese companies in Hong Kong is down 19% from five months ago.

The yuan weakened 0.3% to its lowest since December 28.

Hao Hong, chief strategist at Bocom International Holdings:

• There’s still a lot of selling pressure. Investors are rushing to exit to avoid risk.

• “Lots of people listened to brokers’ advice to build positions around 3 000, betting on a rebound. They are now under big pressure to sell.”

• Main reason for the plunge in Chinese stocks is slowing economic growth rather than pledged shares or the trade war.

• “The key thing is that fundamentals in China are very bad. The market started to correct even before the trade war flared up.”

• Hard to say shares have hit a bottom. And it’s hard for the government to solve the issue as it can’t flood the markets with new money.

Tai Hui, JPMorgan Asset Management Inc. chief APAC market strategist:

• Market volatility in China is brought about by combination of factors: US-China trade tension, concern over corporate bond defaults and uncertainty on the growth outlook .

• Corporate bond defaults are arguably biggest worry at this point. Sentiment toward equities is likely to remain cautious for rest of this year.

• Many onshore investors are mindful that authorities have deleveraging and financial risk reduction as a long-term objective, despite their willingness to provide liquidity near term.

• Trade dispute impact is probably exaggerated. Many Chinese companies focus domestically and don’t have direct trade links with the US.

• Consumer sentiment in China remains positive. See structural demand for consumer services, such as health care and education services.

long way down

Sun Jianbo, China Vision Capital president in Beijing:

• This is a typical bear market where the index keeps falling below supportive levels.

• Not the bottom yet. Pessimism will keep growing as many companies are on the edge of margin calls and bond defaults. Those will cause further selloffs.

• Shanghai Composite could fall at least another 10%.

• Some long-term funds, including the so-called national team, may be interested in buying in the bear market zone

Qian Qimin, Shenwan Hongyuan strategist based in Shanghai:

• Plunge in US stocks overnight hurt confidence. NOTE: S&P 500 fell 1.4% on Monday, biggest loss since April 6 .

• Liquidity usually very tight in banking system as end of June approaches.

• Weakening yuan is hurting companies with high levels of dollar debt and exporters, dragging down some large caps such as airlines Chinese Airlines.

• Don’t see the bottom yet. The market may keep falling since it’s still hard to gauge the impact of trade tensions and investors will keep cutting risk.

Catherine Yeung, investment director at Fidelity International:

• Markets initially rose Monday following RRR cut, but the trade issue overhang is taking centre stage and will probably see a lot more volatility.

• China may do more to support market, potentially ramping up fixed asset investment, though it still needs to go through the deleveraging process.

• The People’s Bank of China is in a better place than other central banks because it still has the tool set.Consumers are still spending.

• Not beyond the realm of possibility for China long term to do bilateral deals with everyone else outside of the US, which surely isn’t good for American consumers.

• China could still be an outperforming market this year because we’ve already seen it down, and maybe developed markets will see some outflows due to ongoing tensions.

• The Chinese government has a flexible approach in terms of policy tools. Data show economic slowdown, but coming from a very high base.

Lu Jie, head of China research at Robeco Investment Management:

• Amid A-share selloff, foreign investors would favor defensive stocks such as consumer goods that benefit from consumption upgrade while avoiding hit from trade war.

• Upward trend in foreign fund inflows to China A shares is just beginning.

• “I had roadshows in Singapore on June 19 when A shares tumbled, none of the investors I met asked questions about the market slump.”

• Foreign investors asked two questions: if China will have an economic crisis and whether Chinese companies will improve corporate governance.

* Sign up to Fin24's top news in your inbox: SUBSCRIBE TO FIN24 NEWSLETTER
Brent Crude
All Share
Top 40
Financial 15
Industrial 25
Resource 10
All JSE data delayed by at least 15 minutes morningstar logo
Company Snapshot
Voting Booth
Do you think it was a good idea for the government to approach the IMF for a $4.3 billion loan to fight Covid-19?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Yes. We need the money.
11% - 934 votes
It depends on how the funds are used.
74% - 6255 votes
No. We should have gotten the loan elsewhere.
15% - 1285 votes