The struggling gold sector would be forced to close more mine shafts if labour unions’ wage demands were implemented, according to the top producer of the precious metal.
The largest union in the gold industry, the National Union of Mineworkers (NUM), this week said it’s deadlocked over pay with companies including Sibanye Gold [JSE:SGL] and AngloGold Ashanti [JSE:ANG] after numerous rounds of negotiations.
Producers argue they can’t afford the union’s demands as they struggle to control operating costs, which have prompted the industry to reduce output and cut thousands of jobs.
“You can get quick wins from negotiations but then we end up having to close shafts and businesses - that’s not in the national interest,” Sibanye CEO Neal Froneman said on Thursday. “Their demands will lead to shaft closures.”
Sibanye’s gold production dropped 13% to 598 500 ounces during the first half of this year as fatal accidents disrupted operations.
In July, the company cut its forecast for gold output this year by 6%. And it’s not alone in seeing declines - the country’s gold production fell for a ninth straight month in June as rising costs, aging infrastructure and accidents affect profit and output.
Sibanye, which employs more than 40 000 workers at its gold mining operations in South Africa, had negative cash flow from its gold business, Froneman said. Unions need to “be reasonable” and allow for flexibility in the negotiations, he said.
“We are not generating cash and I think organised labour needs to understand that,” he said. “This perception that we make a lot of money in gold needs to change.”
It would be “dangerous” for the industry if the unions called a strike and work stoppages are unlikely to achieve the desired result, Froneman said. The gold producers in the collective bargaining unit employ about 80 000 workers.
“A strike is not going to intimidate us - it never has and never will, it’s not the right mechanism to resolve these issues,” Froneman said. “We are flexible within the constraints of the business. The unions haven’t moved at all, they need to be flexible.”* Sign up to Fin24's top news in your inbox: SUBSCRIBE TO FIN24 NEWSLETTER