Barclays and others risk losing 'cash cow' on $1 trillion EU bond sale ban

Barclays and others risk losing ‘cash cow’ on $1 trillion EU bond sale ban
Barclays and others risk losing ‘cash cow’ on $1 trillion EU bond sale ban
Andrew Brookes

For ten of the world's biggest banks, past transgressions in the European Union look set to cost them millions of dollars in fees.

Firms including JPMorgan Chase, Citigroup, Bank of America and Barclays Plc have been frozen out of syndicating bond sales for the European Commission’s roughly 800 billion euro ($970 billion) NextGenerationEU programme, which is expected to issue 80 billion euros of debt this year.

The banks have been temporarily barred from the lucrative trades as the bloc assesses whether they've done enough to fix previous breaches of antitrust rules.

The move has the potential to reshape debt league tables for the region, hand hefty fees to smaller competitors and even weigh on bankers' bonuses. Tuesday’s 20-billion euro issuance by the bloc, the largest amount the EU has raised in a single transaction, may have generated more than $20 million in fees, according to estimates by Bloomberg.

Syndications are a "cash cow," said Liam O’Donnell, head of nominal rates at Aberdeen Standard Investments. It "certainly would have been a profitable environment recently with multiple syndications."

The banks affected are a who’s who of global banking with Deutsche Bank AG, Nomura Holdings, UniCredit SpA, NatWest Group, Natixis SA and Credit Agricole SA also barred. Spokespeople for the ten banks declined or didn't respond to requests for comment. IFR reported the news earlier.

"These banks have to demonstrate and to prove that they have taken all the necessary remedial actions which have been demanded by the Commission when deciding about these cases," budget commissioner Johannes Hahn told reporters Tuesday. "We now expect the submission of the necessary information and then of course we have to analyse and assess it. I cannot predict how long it takes."

While the exclusion is unlikely to make or break the trading year for most desks, the scale of the missed fees could snowball. Another two syndications are due before the end of July.

The EU's big-ticket transactions account for a large part of banks' business in the European market for new bond issues this year. The amount of EU bonds that dealer banks have sold this year typically amounts to more than 10% of their transactions in other European bonds, based on data compiled by Bloomberg.

This makes it hard to effectively replace the EU as a source of fee revenue in Europe. Even though other issuers may offer a higher fee than the EU's 0.1% for this maturity, they are nowhere near as prolific in terms of issuance volume.

Primary dealers

The ten banks barred from the syndications are among a list of 39 so-called "primary dealers", which have a responsibility to bid for bonds during regular debt auctions. The EU is expected to begin those in September.

Stopping banks from participating in bond sales is rare, and a first for the EU since it started selling debt in meaningful sizes under its social programme last year. Morgan Stanley temporarily lost its status as a primary dealer of French government bonds in August as a result of transactions that took place in 2015.

In April this year, Bank of America was among banks fined about 28.5 million euros by European Union regulators for colluding in chatrooms on trading of US supra-sovereign, sovereign and agency bonds. And in May, Nomura and UniCredit were among those fined for colluding on euro government bond trading during the region’s sovereign debt crisis.

Investor demand

The missing banks didn’t seem to dent demand Tuesday with around 142 billion euros of investor orders for the offering. The lead managers for Tuesday’s sale were BNP Paribas SA, DZ Bank AG, HSBC Holdings, IMI-Intesa Sanpaolo SpA and Morgan Stanley, with Danske Bank A/S and Banco Santander SA hired as co-leads.

Despite its hardline stance, the EU offered some hope of a swift resolution to the banks it has excluded, assuming they satisfy its requirements.

It is in the EU’s "interest to include all the key players and banks which have qualified themselves for the primary dealer network", Hahn, the commissioner, said.

"But of course the legal aspects have to be respected."

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For only R75 per month, you have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today.
Subscribe to News24
Rand - Dollar
Rand - Pound
Rand - Euro
Rand - Aus dollar
Rand - Yen
Brent Crude
Top 40
All Share
Resource 10
Industrial 25
Financial 15
All JSE data delayed by at least 15 minutes Iress logo
Company Snapshot
Voting Booth
Should pension fund members be allowed to access their savings before retirement?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Yes, it's their money to do with as they please.
33% - 104 votes
No, more people will end up without enough savings in retirement.
37% - 117 votes
Depends on how big the withdrawal limits will be.
30% - 94 votes