Google said to create shopping service unit

Google’s headquarters in Mountain View. (Marcio Jose Sanchez, AP, File)
Google’s headquarters in Mountain View. (Marcio Jose Sanchez, AP, File)

Brussels - Google will create a standalone unit for its shopping service and require it to bid against rivals for ads shown on the top of its search page, in an effort to satisfy European Union (EU) concerns over the display of product results, three people familiar with the investigation said.

Google faces a Thursday deadline to comply with an EU antitrust order for it to give equal treatment in how the search engine shows competitors’ comparison-shopping sites, according to the people, who asked not to be named as the negotiations are private. While the shopping service will remain part of Google, it will operate separately and use its own revenues to bid for ads.

Google was ordered by regulators to stop promoting its own shopping search results over competitors’ and to make changes by September 28 designed to give rivals a better chance to compete, the EU said in June when it fined the company €2.4bn. The company could be fined up to 5% of daily revenue if it fails to comply.

Al Verney, a spokesperson for Google in Brussels, declined to comment. The offer is part of Mountain View, California-based Google’s efforts to comply with the EU order while it challenges the regulators’ findings in court.

Google parent Alphabet reports revenue for Google and its "Other Bets," like self-driving cars and Nest thermostats. The search giant has a few divisions, like YouTube, its hardware unit and cloud-computing business, that operate independently under Google. The new shopping service would fit this model as a division only in Europe.

10 slots

As part of the EU remedies, the company will tweak an advertising panel at the top of the search screen that shows several pictures of products with links to retailers’ websites, one person said.

Each of 10 slots will be auctioned off to give rival sites, such as or Shopzilla, a chance to buy space to show links to retailers. Any changes only affect Google’s sites in Europe.

While Google Shopping can bid for those slots, it will be run separately to ensure that its bids reflect its own operating costs and aren’t subsidised by Google.

Regulators have accepted that the panel is for advertising and slots cannot be given away, the person said. Each slot will be labelled with the name of the service providing the link, such as "By Google," similar to pages that showed up on French and Dutch versions of Google last week.

Google Shopping has grown quickly since 2009 to account for as much as a fifth of the highly profitable ad revenue Google generates, according to industry estimates. Andreas Reiffen, chief executive officer of search firm Crealytics, estimated earlier this year that the format accounts for roughly a quarter of ad revenue in Europe.

Alphabet reported sales in Europe, the Middle East and Africa of $8.5bn during the second quarter, a third of all company revenue.

Alphabet shares rose less than 1% to $937.46 at 11.33 am in New York. They’re up 18% so far this year.

Further fines

After levying the record fine in June, EU regulators have threatened further penalties if Google doesn’t make changes that give customers a chance to choose other shopping comparison services. EU Competition Commissioner Margrethe Vestager said last week that she would start investigating if Google’s offer "doesn’t work" and if companies that complained about Google’s behavior are still unhappy.

Europe has become a battleground for regulators and technology giants, with Apple ordered by the EU to pay some €13bn in back tax and Germany examining whether Facebook unfairly compels users to sign over personal data. Google may face more fines over its Android mobile-phone software and AdSense advertising service in two other EU cases due to be finalised soon.

Richard Stables, chief executive officer of Kelkoo, said Google’s offer to sell rivals slots was worse than the search engine’s 2013 attempt to settle the EU case. Anyone who believes such an offer will resolve problems in the shopping search market "doesn’t understand how the market works," he said.

Foundem, a UK shopping site, last week slammed an auction for the slots, saying it creates "an additional anti-competitive barrier" that sees companies pay for placement instead of getting traffic for free from relevant search results.

Foundem’s 2009 complaint to the EU helped trigger the probe after it said links to its sites were unfairly pushed down in Google search results. Google had argued that the links were rated less relevant because they weren’t of high quality.

SUBSCRIBE FOR FREE UPDATE: Get Fin24's top morning business news and opinions in your inbox.

Read Fin24's top stories trending on Twitter:

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For only R75 per month, you have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today.
Subscribe to News24
Brent Crude
All Share
Top 40
Financial 15
Industrial 25
Resource 10
All JSE data delayed by at least 15 minutes morningstar logo
Company Snapshot
Voting Booth
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Yes, and I've gotten it.
21% - 383 votes
No, I did not.
52% - 945 votes
My landlord refused
27% - 498 votes