Ask an expert

21 Jan 2009

Is Rent for children too much?
Dear Doc

My husband' s 2 sons, age 23 and 25 moved in with us over a year ago. They both work, earn more then R5000 a month each,and pay R500 rent p/m, since they' ve started working. I have a good relationship with both of them. However, i' m beginning to think me and hubby might have a problem. I dont know if i' m just selfish and inconsiderate, that' s why i want advice. Before they moved In ,it was only me, my husband, and our daughther of 15. My husband is still finacially taking care of everything, as i am a housewife. It never was a problem for him before, but now he really struggles finacially, so much so that , against his wishes,i' m seriously seeking for a job, just to help him pay the bills. I tried talking to him to increase the 2 boys' s rent, but he just says that things will get better, and that they also have their bills to pay. But pls help me here: These kids both have their own seperate bedrooms, they use our vehicles, they eat everyday,whether i cook or not, i do their washing, they take lunch to work, but wont even buy bread or washing powder if there' s isnt any, they would rather much wait till i finally decide to buy it. Our water& electricity acc is over R1200 each month, which hubby has to pay on his own. Hubby even pays for the cars damages whenever they bumped it. They dont do anything in or around the house to help me or my husband, but still they use all our facilities available. Hubby n me cant even afford to treat ourselves anymore, where they on the other hand can afford all sorts of expensive luxeries and trips.We' re staying in Pretoria for 3years now, and from what i' ve heard, people r paying +- R3500 in our area just for a 1 bedroom flat. Please dont get me wrong, i really love these 2 children, but i do feel they r adults now, and i feel they would never face their responsibilities as long as we keep on spoiling them like this, However doc, if u really think i' m just a selfish mother, and moan over nothing, i' d find another way to solve this problem, as i really dont want to ruin my relationship with my stepchildren nor my husband, and that' s exactly what i think will happen if i confront this issue with hubby again.
Answer 445 views

01 Jan 0001

Why did they move in with you rather than getting their own places, separately or together ? They're old enough to do so. Why is your husband now struggling financially, if he had no problems before ? Are the boys costing more than they payn ? IF so, tell them their rent must go up to meet costs, or they can find their own place. No point in allowing them to eat you out of house and home. If its the general financial situation that's causing the problems, then still they should contribute more --- if they were staying at a hotel and the costs went up to the hotel, their room rate would go up --- the hotel wouldn't go bankrupt just to suit their convenience.
I don't undertand your husband's atitude. If the boys stay with you and everything is provided for them, --- WHAT bills do they also have to pay ? And drink and entertainment bills don't count as an excuse.
No way they shoud use your vehicles without paying extra for that. And they must pay in full for any damages they cause --- otherwise why would they even need to drive safely. Of course they should share the chores round the house, just as they would have to if they were living non their own. The amount they're paing is ridiculously low --- they'd find it hard to find a hotel room for less than R 500 a night, let alone a month,.
You're being sensible, not selfish, and he is spoiling them ridiculously. Why does he feel so guilty and responsible for this pair of irrecp[onsible adults ?
The information provided does not constitute a diagnosis of your condition. You should consult a medical practitioner or other appropriate health care professional for a physical examination, diagnosis and formal advice. Health24 and the expert accept no responsibility or liability for any damage or personal harm you may suffer resulting from making use of this content.