Ask an expert

11 Jan 2005

When friends are judgemental???
I have a very broad question I would like to ask? Can one be a good friend if you are a judgemental and close minded person. I believe that even if a friend does something you do not specifically condone, it is not your job as a friend to judge her/or him (yes, you can tell that person that you dont really think the behaviour is right) but you should be there to pick up the pieces afterwards or be able to be happy for that person no matter what. We all make mistakes and its easy to judge someone if you havent been in their shoes. You never know how you will handle a situation until you are faced with it yourself. What are your views on this.
Answer 355 views

01 Jan 0001

I notice the word "judgemental" gets used a lot round here, without much clarity as to its meaning. It may be "judgemental" to be always judging other people about everything, and to set oneself up as the arbiter who always knows wat everyone else ought to do. But it's not judgemental to have personal opinions about right and wrong, and to disapprove of behaviors widely considered to be wrong. Then the complaint that someone is being judgemental is usually coming from someone who knows that they're doing something wrong and don't want anyone to remind them of that. Your task as a friend isn't to aid and abet someone who is doing wrong, or to encourage them automatically --- though you may be prepared to help them pick up the pieces and recover once they recognize that it was, indeed, wrong.
And we cant and mustnt reject advice on the fake grounds that the person hasn't been in that situation themselves. We know that heroin addiction is bad for a person, and don't need to addict ourselves in order to know that. We know that jumping over a cliff is harmful, even if we have never jumped over one. Again, the "Aah, but you've neer been in this situation yourself" argument is usually just another way of avoiding facing the fact that one is harming oneself and/or someone else.
As adults we may claim the right to make our own decisions about what we will do, but we don't have the right ( nor would it be anything but stupid to try it ) to ignore the advice and opinions of others, and of society at large, when making such decisions.
As a friend, out for a walk with a pal, you'd feel it your duty to warn them if you saw that they were about to fall into a hole or that they'd forgotten to check for traffic when about to cross a road --- don't you have a similar duty to warn in interpersonal circumstances, too ?
The information provided does not constitute a diagnosis of your condition. You should consult a medical practitioner or other appropriate health care professional for a physical examination, diagnosis and formal advice. Health24 and the expert accept no responsibility or liability for any damage or personal harm you may suffer resulting from making use of this content.
Voting Booth
Have you entered our Health of the Nation survey?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
32% - 9432 votes
68% - 19962 votes