Used pacemakers a new lease on life

Chandrakan Pawar is lucky to be alive. In September, the Indian former textile mill worker was given a pacemaker after his heart rate plunged to just 20 to 30 beats per minute.

On the face of it, his case was not unusual, with the use of pacemakers to correct abnormal heart rates now commonplace around the world. What was more unusual is that his pacemaker was "second-hand".

Instead of a new device, the 61-year-old from Mumbai was given a free reconditioned pacemaker that had been used previously by a patient in the United States and removed after their death.

I feel much better now. There's no giddiness, said Pawar, who suffered three years of black-outs due to his low pulse. It's like a new life, he told AFP.

Like finding bullion

The privately run Holy Family Hospital in Mumbai, where he was treated, has been receiving second-hand pacemakers from the United States for the last decade under an innovative scheme designed to help its poorest patients.

The doctor behind the initiative, Daniel Mascarenhas, has also provided other equipment, including coronary stents tubes and implantable defibrillators, which send electric shocks to correct abnormal heart rhythms.

All the devices have either been removed from patients or were unused but past their expiry dates, the Indian-born cardiologist, who practises in Pennsylvania, said in a phone interview.

Some consultants play golf. I go to funeral homes, he said. When I find a pacemaker device which has five years of life left, it's like finding bullion.

Sterilised and reconditioned

It makes me happy because it's going to help someone who can't afford the treatment in India.

Mascarenhas and his colleague from the University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston, Bharat Kantharia, highlighted the scheme in an article in the American Journal of Cardiology in October.

Between 2004 and 2010, they said 53 permanent pacemakers (PPMs) donated from US funeral homes were sterilised, reconditioned and used by the Holy Family Hospital.

Of those, 37 were implanted in new patients while 16 were given to those requiring replacement devices.

Improved quality of life

No significant complications, including infections or device failures, were found when patients were tracked, the doctors said, calling the procedure safe and effective.

Implantation of donated PPMs can not only save lives but also improve quality of life of needy patients.

The charitable scheme highlights the problems of access to quality healthcare in India, which is seeing spiralling rates of heart disease due to rapid lifestyle changes.

On the one hand, the booming economy has led to a buoyant private healthcare sector with world-class facilities and care, plus the development of a medical tourism industry, enticing patients from around the world.

Expensive in India

But the majority of India's 1.2 billion people are still forced to rely on a massively over-stretched, under-funded public health system with crumbling, dirty and overcrowded hospitals.

Low-income families often are forced to take loans to cover basic medical fees.

A new pacemaker, which in India can cost up to R25 000 and lasts around 10 years, is for most people prohibitively expensive.

There's a tremendous need, said Mascarenhas, adding that patients were dying for lack of equipment or the cost of treatment. It's a sad state of affairs.

Ethical objections

Mascarenhas and Kantharia, who both trained in Mumbai, said they would like to expand the scheme but were aware that regulatory issues were a potential stumbling block.

US-based cardiac arrhythmia specialist David Martin also said a risk adverse climate inhibits makers and regulators from sanctioning re-use of the devices, which are labelled single-use only.

There could be objections on ethical grounds from patients and their families, he added.

And even if those hurdles were overcome, the treatment may still be unaffordable because pacemaker leads are not re-usable, said Martin, from the Lahey Medical Centre in Burlington, Massachusetts.

A blessing

But the specialist, who heads the non-profit Project Pacer International group, which provides cardiac treatment in developing countries, said there were plus points.

Getting consent from the patient's family is mandatory and unlikely to be a problem in most cases since time is not of the essence and most people readily see the enormous benefit they can give to another life, he said by email.

As for Pawar's family, where the pacemaker came from is immaterial.

I just think it's God's blessing, said his wife, Chhaya.

(Sapa, Novemeber 2011) 

Read more:

Second hand pacemakers

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For only R75 per month, you have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today.
Subscribe to News24
Voting Booth
Have you entered our Health of the Nation survey?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
29% - 9744 votes
71% - 23868 votes