Assessment tools useless in psychopaths


Assessment tools used to predict how likely a psychopathic prisoner is to re-offend if freed from jail are "utterly useless" and parole boards might just as well flip a coin when deciding such risks, psychiatrists said.

Publishing a study that found risk score tools are only around 46% accurate on how likely psychopathic convicts are to kill, rape or assault again, they said probation officers and judges should set little or no store by such tests.

They warned that clinicians carrying out such classifications must be aware of their severe limitations, and make sure prisoners undergo a comprehensive psychiatric diagnosis before any risk assessment is made.

"If you apply these (tests) to somebody who is a psychopath, they're utterly useless, you might as well toss a coin," said Dr Jeremy Coid, director of the forensic psychiatry research unit at Queen Mary University of London who led the study."They will not predict accurately at all," he told reporters at a briefing in London about his findings.

Coid and other forensic psychiatrists say the findings which also showed the tools perform only moderately well in prisoners with disorders like schizophrenia, depression and drug and alcohol dependence could have major implications for risk assessment in criminal justice systems.

Public protection

"There are increasing expectations of public protection from violent behaviour, and psychiatrists can be seriously criticised if they make wrong decisions," he said. Dr Seena Fazel, a consultant forensic psychiatrist at Britain's University of Oxford, said the reliability of the tests' predictive ability was so low that it might be best not to use them at all and warned that at the very least, their results should only be noted by parole boards, rather than acted upon. "If you're going to use these instruments, be aware of their strengths and limitations," he told reporters.

The estimated prevalence of adult psychopathy in the general population is around 1%, but that rises to between 15% and 25% among men in prison.

Coid, whose study was published in the British Journal of Psychiatry, analysed data from 1 396 male prisoners in England and Wales who were interviewed between 6 and 12 months before their release.

All the men were serving sentences of two or more years for a sexual or violent offence. The prisoners were assessed for personality disorders, symptoms of schizophrenia, depression and drug and alcohol dependence, and were measured for psychopathy on a reputable scale known as Hare Psychopathy Check List.

Low accuracy

After their release, data on their re-offending rates was added to the study, and showed that among three different re-offending risk assessment tools used before their release, the accuracy among psychopaths was below 50%.

While the tools were more accurate in predictions for prisoners with no mental health disorders at around 75% accuracy they were only around 60% right when it came to prisoners diagnosed with schizophrenia and depression.

For prisoners with anti-social personality disorders the predictive value of the tests ranged from poor to little more than chance, with an average 53.2% predictive accuracy. And for the 70 prisoners rated as psychopathic, none of the tests was statistically better than chance.

Coid said the results suggest it is time to question the expectations put on psychiatrists and psychologists asked to forecast future behaviour of offenders, and to consider what can happen to their reputations if predictions are wrong."The easy solution is to be highly restrictive on who is released, and be risk averse."

"However, even for serious offenders, most will be released at some stage and someone has to carry out a risk assessment," he said. "We need to prioritise the development of new assessment tools for these hard-to-predict groups."

Picture: Scary man from Shutterstock
We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For only R75 per month, you have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today.
Subscribe to News24
Voting Booth
Have you entered our Health of the Nation survey?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
29% - 9753 votes
71% - 24010 votes