On Wednesday last week, a sick patient arrived at closed gates at Madimbo Clinic in Mutale in the Vhembe district of Limpopo, according to Democratic Alliance spokesperson for health in the province, Risham Maharaj.
In a statement, Maharaj said the patient arrived at the gates around 05:30 and was “kept outside waiting for medical attention” for an hour and a half because staff allegedly said they only open a 07:00 am. Madimbo is a 24-hour clinic.
The patient was referred to Donald Fraser Hospital (90kms away) where she passed away that evening. On the same morning at the same clinic, another patient reportedly went into labour in front of the closed gates.
Limpopo Department of Health spokesperson Neil Shikwambana confirmed the incidents and told Spotlight emergency medical services took both women to the Donald Fraser Hospital where the mother and child turned out fine but the other patient died.
According to him, the department is still investigating the incidents and the nurse that was on duty at the clinic has since been suspended.
Like Madimbo Clinic, many clinics in Limpopo appear to be operating without the required number of staff needed to deliver quality healthcare services. According to a recent report from Ritshidze, a community healthcare monitoring project, almost 70% of the 385 patients they interviewed, said there was not enough staff to meet patients’ needs.
Activists say these staff shortages also contribute to long waiting times for patients and overworked staff - which can ultimately undermine the province’s HIV programme.
The report, released on 26 August, is based on the monitoring of 17 clinics and community healthcare centres in Limpopo between April and June this year.
Short-staffed and unsafe
Vacancies, mostly of professional and enrolled nurses in clinics, were one of the big challenges flagged in the report. It noted at least 30 vacancies across the 17 facilities. Over 90% of the facility managers interviewed said that “insufficient human resources count as one of their biggest challenges”. These vacancies also included pharmacists and cleaners.
At nine clinics patients report average waiting times of four hours or more and at four clinics some patients said they wait on average for five hours or more to be seen by healthcare workers.
51% of patients reported they felt very unsafe waiting for the clinic to open. “Early mornings, feeling unsafe outside the clinic, and long waiting times cause people to dread clinic days or even stop going. This directly impacts our ability to reach 95% of people living with HIV on treatment,” the report reads.
According to the report, a circular from the national Department of Health in 2019 instructed facility management that these public health facilities “must be open from 05:00 to 19:00, as well as from 8:00 to 16:00 on Saturdays”.
The report asserts that these opening times are not possible in many of the facilities due to staff shortages.
Shikwambana said although there are 24-hour clinics in the province, some had to close due to safety and security issues. He acknowledged staff shortages are a big concern. “We are working on a human resources structure that will speak to our service needs,” he said, adding that they started on a “turnaround plan two or three years ago”.
According to Shikwambana, the department’s salary bill is about two-thirds of its entire budget. “So, we may have shortages, but the salary bill shows the workers are there”, he said. “We may have a high vacancy rate, but in reality on Persal, we have a lot of personnel.”
He also said they are making the management structure less top-heavy and that they have reduced the number of deputy director-generals in the department from six to four. When people retire, Shikwambana said, they rationalise positions so that senior personnel get additional responsibilities. He stressed, however, that there is only so much the department can do because it needs organised labour on board and negotiations around staffing are ongoing and takes time.
When pressed on when healthcare users who depend on these clinic services will see a difference in staffing levels, Shikwambana couldn’t say. “We can’t make commitments, it depends on processes. It’s a complex issue,” he said.
Figures in the Limpopo health department’s annual report for 2019/20 show that in district health services by 31 March 2020, there were 44 924 approved posts but only 23 024 of these posts were filled at the time, which means a vacancy rate of almost 50% for district health. The vacancy rate for professional nurses in the province stood at 35%.
Under “desired service standards”, the department noted in this annual report among things they will improve are “timeous payment of suppliers to ensure sustained supply of medicines for 12 months in a financial year, decongest facilities to effect friendlier services (utilising CCMDD), improve stock management and better demand planning and forecasting to effect continuous supply of essential medicines, [and] better human resource utilisation to extend hours of service”.
What actually happened, as reported by the department, however, is that “medicines availability has been below target at all levels due to some of the essential items not awarded on new national contracts”.
According to the Ritshidze data, 38% of patients interviewed “left, or knew someone who left, a clinic without the medication they needed”. It was mostly contraceptives that patients reported as being out of stock, but some patients also reported having left the clinic without HIV and TB medicines.
Facility managers at the clinics said when the clinic experienced stockouts, in “50% [of cases they] were forced to send people away empty-handed, and [in] 50% [of cases they] gave them an alternative”.
At some of the clinics, such as Perskebult Clinic, HIV medicine was the biggest challenge. At Perskebult and Grace Mugodeni Community Health Centre, reports of stockouts of contraceptives were also flagged. Clinic in Ga-Mothapo Village, Polokwane and Perskebult Clinic received the worst scores for stockouts.
“Stockouts and shortages of ARVs, TB medicines, contraceptives, and other medicines cause disruption, confusion, cost, and can detrimentally affect treatment adherence,” the report reads.
The Ritshidze project recommends that the department should develop a “provincial strategy to address stockouts and shortages of medicines and other medical tools and supplies” by February 2022.
Shikwambana told Spotlight the stockouts are not unique to Limpopo and that these problems are common across provinces. “There are often issues with medicine suppliers and we also rely on the international medical markets. We are not trying to shift the responsibility, he said, but there are many factors at play in medicine supply.
Shikwambana said the department will work through the contents of the Ritshidze report and will then decide on the best way forward.
The provincial department of health has flagged issues around “courtesy of healthcare workers” as a concern in its annual report. The department reported it has a “complaints management system that enables [it] to monitor whether patients are treated with courtesy”.
The department acknowledged in the report, however, that there have been “a few incidences of negative attitude towards patients”, but said that the issue has been addressed.
The Ritshidze report paints a different picture. The report highlights, among others, “the discriminatory and insensitive attitude some nurses and clinic staff have toward key populations, including sex workers and members of the LGBTQI community”.
According to the chair of the Treatment Action Campaign (TAC) Sibongile Tshabalala, the data shows that these staff attitudes are among the various reasons the province has not reached the 95-95-95 targets. The TAC is one of the partner organisations in the Ritshidze project.
The 95 targets refer to the UNAIDS strategy aimed at 95% of people living with HIV being aware of their status, 95% of those who know their status being on antiretroviral therapy (ART), and 95% of those on treatment being virally suppressed - all by 2025. (The UNAIDS targets for 2025 also include some additional goals.)
According to the report, while 91% of people living with HIV know their status in Limpopo, only 73% of those people are on HIV treatment, out of which 87% are virally suppressed.
Tshabalala on the Ritshidze blog said, “Only 57.9% of patients thought that the staff were always friendly and professional. This lack of professionalism and bullying attitudes by some nurses have come to define the experiences of many patients reliant on Limpopo’s clinics.
"We need a clear strategy to change this as it inflames tensions between communities and their local healthcare workers. Most devastatingly, it has removed trust and confidence in the healthcare system and has resulted in dire impacts on patients’ care.”
The report found that 59% of people living with HIV surveyed said staff at clinics shouted at them if they miss an appointment with 12% alleging that they were sent to the back of the queue for missing an appointment.
Shikwambana said, “anything that has the ability to derail the province’s efforts against HIV, is concerning”. He encouraged health users, especially in rural areas, to use the department’s complaint processes to report such incidents.
Note:A representative of theTAC is quoted in this article and the TAC is part of the Ritshidze project. Spotlight is published by SECTION27 and the TAC, but is editorially independent, an independence that the editors guard jealously. Spotlight is a member of the South African Press Council.
*This article was produced by Spotlight - health journalism in the public interest.