#ShockWildlifeTruths: To fight wildlife crime, experts say 'follow the money'

Istock Photograph
Istock Photograph

Bangkok — In most cases, the conviction of a Thai man trafficking rhino horns through a bizarre scheme that involved hiring prostitutes to pose as trophy hunters would have marked the end of the story.

But investigators took an unusual, next step — deciding to "follow the money" that helped bankroll the South African operation, and ultimately winning a court order last year to seize Chumlong Lemtongthai's Thai bank accounts and other assets, including a house worth $142 000 (about R1.8 m @R13.23/$), to shut him down.

Shifting tactics

It was one of an increasing number of cases illustrating how nations are shifting tactics in fighting a global wildlife trafficking market worth up to $23 billion, with the headline-grabbing police raids having little overall effect in halting illicit trades.

ALSO SEE: Confiscated rhino horn at OR Tambo 'not linked to online auction'

The idea is "to pick the pocket of the wildlife traffickers and try to freeze them in their tracks," says Steve Galster, founder of the anti-trafficking Freeland Foundation.

This week, the UN General Assembly passed a resolution urging its 193 members to adopt laws making wildlife crimes offences that can trigger money laundering investigations and allow assets to be seized. Existing legal tools for fighting corruption, racketeering and financial crime should also be used to combat traffickers, it says.

Crime gangs are increasingly turning to wildlife smuggling as a lucrative trade. And as they become more sophisticated with their technology and financial arrangements, national customs agents and police have struggled to keep up.

MUST-SEE: #ShockWildlifeTruths: Plans for second rhino online auction underway

Experts say they need to begin adopting tools commonly used to fight drug lords and other crime kingpins: anti-money laundering techniques and financial investigation.

"We've gone beyond kicking down the door and looking for animals in the back room, to looking at who's the kingpin, who's the transportation coordinator, who ultimately is the vulnerable node in the syndicate without whom the syndicate wouldn't work," says Galster, whose group has teamed up with law enforcement agencies to bring down several trafficking rings in recent years.

A new report this week calls this expanded effort "urgent," given how quickly crime gangs are evolving into cross-border wildlife trades.

Financial investigations after every bust

Agencies fighting wildlife crime need to conduct financial investigations after every bust — to identify broader criminal networks and uncover criminal proceeds, which can be frozen or confiscated, says the report by the Royal United Services Institute, a British think tank.

SEE: How SA's Rhino Peak Challenge and Botswana's 'Rapid Reference Guide' helps endangered species

Suspicious transactions and bank clients can be "red flagged" for agencies including financial intelligence units to monitor and investigate, the report says. Watch lists of alleged poachers can be shared.

"We've been very slow to recognise wildlife crime as serious transnational organised crime," said Cathy Haenlein, one of the report's authors.

The trafficking epidemic has surged as incomes have risen in Asia. In just the past few months, authorities in Malaysia, Thailand, Vietnam and Indonesia have seized tons of carved ivory, ivory tusks, rhino horns, live pangolins and pangolin scales. The busts included Hong Kong's biggest ivory haul in three decades — a shipment worth nearly $10 million.

But arrests are rarely reported, aside from low level smugglers.

SEE: Kruger Poaching War: two attempts stopped as online auction commences

For too long, nations saw wildlife trafficking as an issue for conservationists, Haenlein says. That's allowed traffickers to flourish — using crypto-currency markets to make illicit bulk trades, or stockpiling durable animal parts like pangolin scales or elephant tusks in an attempt to corner the market.

That makes the problem of wildlife trafficking even more acute, giving traffickers perverse incentive to drive down a species' population so that the value of their stockpile goes up even further.

But international investigators and countries' crime units are catching on.

Now, "it's very clear that it is about the money," Haenlein says. And addressing the gap in the chain of smuggling, between those poaching the animals and moving parts and those financing the operations, "could have the potential to change the game."

Drawing expertise from anti-corruption and financial crime units

In January, Interpol said it was going after high-profile Asian traffickers sourcing wildlife from Africa, by drawing expertise from anti-corruption and financial crime units, as well as a digital forensics labs that can extract data from seized electronic equipment.

Some investigators are starting to track sea shipments and compare data on who is booking suspicious cargo transports around the globe.

"A large seizure often has interesting facts around it," says Julian Newman of the Environmental Investigation Agency. For example, "money has been moved somewhere to book a container (for the smuggled goods) and put it on a ship."

SEE: 7th key rhino horn bust in SA for 2017 as Zim woman nabbed at OR Tambo

Only by following the money will investigators track down the kingpins and financiers, who "never touch the stuff, they handle it through proxies," Newman says.

But countries still aren't moving fast enough to keep up, and they still rarely follow the financial breadcrumbs, according to a July report by the Asia-Pacific Group on Money Laundering and the UN Office on Drugs and Crime.

Only a dozen or so governments of 45 surveyed have said they're using financial investigation techniques, seizing assets or pursuing money laundering charges for wildlife cases, the July report says.

"Financial investigations don't come for free or cheap," says Chris Batt, a UNODC adviser who led the study. "You've got to train and commit (investigators) for the cause."

Small but rare victory

The case of Chumlong, the Thai rhino horn trafficker, was a small but rare victory.

He had been sent to South Africa by a notorious Southeast Asian trafficking syndicate called the Xaysavang network to take advantage of its permit system for professional trophy hunts. Chumlong hired prostitutes to pose as hunters and organised sham expeditions during which 26 rhinos were shot and killed, according to court documents.

The scheme involved doctoring customs papers before shipping the rhino horns to Laos. Once convicted, Chumlong was sentenced to 13 years in South African prison after appeals.

The decision to go after Chumlong's assets was made only in 2016, after agents received training in asset recovery. However, the alleged kingpin of the Xaysavang network, Vixay Keosavang, of Laos, remains at large with a US bounty of $1 million on his head.

SEE: Wildlife Act responds to John Hume ahead of delayed online rhino horn auction

Experts say asset seizures can act as powerful deterrents in persuading criminals to avoid getting into the wildlife racket.

They can also offer incentives for governments, who can invest some of those seized assets in the law-enforcement agencies that are working to bring down wildlife crime.

Other examples underscore how much work remains to be done.

In a 2014 case, Freeland helped Thai authorities to identify and freeze $37 million in assets linked to a tiger trafficking ring in the country's northeast. The ringleader remains free, however, and the case has been stalled and might never go to the prosecutor's office.

What to read next on Traveller24:

Confiscated rhino horn at OR Tambo 'not linked to online auction'

Australia and New Zealand are letting elephant and rhino down

#ShockWildlifeTruths: Plans for second rhino online auction underway

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For only R75 per month, you have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today.
Subscribe to News24
Lockdown For
DAYS
HRS
MINS
Voting Booth
As a child or as an adult, have you ever been a victim of bullying?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Results
Yes, at school
55% - 4045 votes
Yes, at work
18% - 1300 votes
No, I've never experienced this
27% - 2014 votes
Vote
USD/ZAR
14.32
(+0.5)
GBP/ZAR
19.85
(-0.0)
EUR/ZAR
17.25
(+0.6)
AUD/ZAR
11.07
(+0.2)
JPY/ZAR
0.13
(+0.3)
Gold
1,784.03
(-0.5)
Silver
26.34
(-0.8)
Platinum
1,208.97
(-0.7)
Brent Crude
65.32
(-1.9)
Palladium
2,856.75
(-0.8)
All Share
66,973
(-0.3)
Top 40
61,191
(-0.3)
Financial 15
12,120
(-0.1)
Industrial 25
86,738
(0.0)
Resource 10
68,694
(-0.8)
All JSE data delayed by at least 15 minutes Iress logo