Alcohol ban and taxi capacity: Govt is going about it wrong, say experts

  • Two experts say a better plan is needed to manage the increase in Covid-19 infections, especially in terms of banning alcohol sales.
  • They say alternatives need to be thought up instead of implementing a ban on alcohol sales.
  • Both also raised concerns about the announcement that taxis driving short distances would be allowed 100% capacity.

Two medical experts have expressed concern following government's renewed ban on alcohol sales and regulations on taxi capacity.

The experts, who also serve on the Ministerial Advisory Committee (MAC), said government need to come up with a more comprehensive plan on how to manage the increase in Covid-19 infections.

This follows President Cyril Ramaphosa's address to the nation on Sunday night in which he announced taxis driving short distances could do so at 100% capacity provided windows were open, a nationwide sales ban on alcohol as well as a curfew.

Alcohol

Speaking to News24, Dr Angelique Coetzee, the president of the South African Medical Association (SAMA) and member of the MAC, said the ban on alcohol would impact workers' livelihoods and a better plan needed to be created.

She added it seemed South Africans had a major issue with alcohol abuse, which had contributed to an increase in causality cases in hospitals.

While the ban might be needed, Coetzee said the government could look at measures that were "less harsh".

"You are willing to risk 100% loading of a taxi, but you're not willing to risk and come up with a better solution than just shutting down all the alcohol outlets."

She suggested other measures to curb alcohol consumption, including limiting outlet times, but more importantly, looking at the cause of why people abused alcohol.

Coetzee said that needed to be addressed because "the moment they lift the ban, it's going to happen again".

READ | No booze, a new curfew and no family gatherings, says Ramaphosa

For Professor Francois Venter, the head of the Ezintsha Health Unit at the University of the Witwatersrand and member of the MAC, there were more creative ways to relieve some pressure on the healthcare system other than an alcohol ban.

He said while an argument could be made to ban alcohol in hard-hit provinces like Gauteng, "there is no reason" the ban should apply in areas which did not have high Covid-19 infections as healthcare systems in these areas were under less stress.

Venter added he believed the measures announced were a distraction from the measures "we should be talking about, like physical distancing, hand-washing and mask-wearing".

He said the government needed to be consistent in its regulations to build trust and buy-in from the public to fight Covid-19.

"The government has shot itself in the foot repeatedly with irrational advice and what happens then is that it's very easy for society to opt out and to say, 'this is nonsense, I'm not going to participate'."

ALSO READ | Ramaphosa calls out South Africans for 'reckless' behaviour during Covid-19 regulations

"I think what I was really disappointed with, was not enough attention to public transport, to the taxi industry. 

"They should have been talking about what they were doing about that and reinforcing the physical distancing, etc, which he did but instead it did feel a bit like a moral admonishment, like your father talking to you, when government really have not held up its end of the social contract - irrational guidelines, inconsistent laws - and for that reason I think people will just shrug their shoulders and say 'whatever'."

Venter added while Ramaphosa spoke about mask-wearing, the focus should have been on emphasising a social contract.

"It should be more about us policing communities and say it's not OK to have our masks off in public, and for your youngest to go to a party is not OK, you need to start thinking about the consequences of that.

"I'm quite disappointed, I must say."

Curfew

While Coetzee said the SAMA had been calling for a curfew for a while now, she believed the one announced by Ramaphosa on Sunday started too late and ended too early to be effective.

"As long as the curfew can keep people at home, then it can help," she added, saying it would not have an effect because of the times.

For those going to parties, Coetzee said it would especially not have an impact, as young people could simply stay at the party until the curfew ended.

Taxi capacity

Ramaphosa said taxis driving long distances would only be able to fill up to 70% capacity, while short-distance taxis could fill 100%, provided they opened windows for ventilation.

Coetzee said importance should be placed on ventilation inside taxis as mounting research had suggested Covid-19 was airborne.

Along with social distancing, sanitising and mask-wearing, ventilation was an important measure that needed to be put in place, she added.

"What is not clear, is what is long distancing and what are normal distances.

"For short distance, it is very clear that when you are 100% loaded in your taxi, all the literature is showing that contact time should not be longer than 20 minutes in very close contact."

Coetzee raised concerns over this, saying it could create a contradiction in terms of the regulations if the government allowed people to be in close contact with each other for more than 20 minutes.

"Then why don't you just open up all the restaurants or churches? [...] There should not be two different versions of what is 'close contact'," she said.

Venter believed the biggest failure from the government was in its handling of issues in the taxi industry.

"Why not work with them and say these are the things we think are going to keep your drivers safe and a way we can keep the industry going?

"Instead, now we have a situation where, I think, it will be one of the single biggest way people will be infected other than at home," he said.

Lockdown For
DAYS
HRS
MINS
Voting Booth
The Rugby Championship looks set to be hosted November and December, with New Zealand a likely destination. Would you be confident in the Boks defending their title?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Results
No, the Boks will be undercooked compared to their Australian and New Zealand counterparts.
35% - 1482 votes
The All Blacks will win easily if all the games are staged in New Zealand.
24% - 1031 votes
Underprepared or not, the Boks should jump at any sort of opportunity to play Test rugby.
41% - 1717 votes
Vote
ZAR/USD
17.20
(-0.08)
ZAR/GBP
22.49
(-0.04)
ZAR/EUR
20.24
(-0.11)
ZAR/AUD
12.26
(-0.24)
ZAR/JPY
0.16
(+0.03)
Gold
2016.30
(+2.16)
Silver
25.89
(+6.95)
Platinum
939.00
(+2.23)
Brent Crude
43.86
(+1.45)
Palladium
2132.99
(+2.41)
All Share
56248.93
(+0.75)
Top 40
51951.34
(+0.74)
Financial 15
9878.55
(+0.75)
Industrial 25
74943.49
(+0.27)
Resource 10
57327.85
(+1.31)
All JSE data delayed by at least 15 minutes morningstar logo