Beitbridge deaths: Motsoaledi denies claims drivers died due to 'horror conditions'

0:00
play article
Subscribers can listen to this article
Home Affairs Minister Aaron Motsoaledi
Home Affairs Minister Aaron Motsoaledi
  • Home affairs minister Aaron Motsoaledi has rubbished claims that four truck drivers died at Beitbridge border post as a result of massive congestion.
  • According to the minister, only one truck driver died but he would not divulge the cause of death.
  • He also dismissed claims that the congestion was a result of poor planning by government.

Home affairs minister Aaron Motsoaledi has rubbished claims that four truck drivers died at the Beitbridge border post as a result of massive congestion.

Between 23 and 26 December reports emerged of snaking queues at the border post in Limpopo with multiple claims that the congestion was a result of poor planning by government.

The Road Freight Association (RFA) claimed that truck drivers had died due to the dire conditions.

RFA chief executive Gavin Kelly was also quoted as saying there were unconfirmed reports that seven other truck drivers had died. This information allegedly came from the local police.

Kelly said there was no food, water or ablution facilities that the truck drivers could make use of.

During a briefing on Wednesday, Motsoaledi slammed these claims, saying that factually inaccurate stories peppered the news and caused a lot of confusion.

Truck driver death

Motsoaledi said the department wrote to the RFA CEO asking for the names of the truck drivers who had allegedly died as per his media statement.

"Yesterday, the CEO referred us to a police officer in Limpopo," Motsoaledi said.

"When we phoned this police officer, he told us that he doesn't know where all this is coming and why we are being referred to him."

Motsoaledi said they will not disclose the cause of death but that the family knew how he had died and never tried to play politics with his death.

The minister added that two other people had died on 23 and 24 December, but they were not in the trucking industry. He said they had died of various ailments that he would not disclose for privacy reasons.

Peaked

"Apart from the truck driver who demised on 23 December 2020, the day the congestion peaked, the other deaths occurred long before the increased activity associated with the holiday season started," Motsoaledi said.

He added: "There was of course some mortality of people who have nothing to do with truck driving but are always in that area."

ALSO READ | Congestion at Beitbridge border post are an indictment on SA immigration and foreign policy

He said mortalities were recorded on 8, 13, 14 and 22 December, before the congestion at the border post.

"Beitbridge is an area of intense human activity where there are many people involved in diverse activities.

"There is a lot of wheeling and dealing in that environment. It would be expecting a miracle to believe such an area of human activity won't have some form of mortality at all.

"Indeed, most people who demised at Beitbridge and if I may add, it is a whole-year event, which has got nothing to do with road congestion as it was widely reported over the Christmas period."

Cause of congestion

The minister also rubbished claims that the congestion was caused by government.

Among the claims were that the department failed to plan ahead and should have foreseen that there would be a lot of travellers crossing the border back to their homes as they were not able to travel earlier because of the Covid-19 lockdown.

"Listening to the media last week, it was generally accepted, as an incontestable fact, that this year there were many more travellers who crossed Beitbridge than was the case in the previous years. Our statistics show otherwise."

According to the department, there was a 27% drop in travellers crossing the Beitbridge border post in December when compared with the same period in 2019.

In December 2019, 368 895 travellers crossed Beitbridge compared to 103 224 crossings recorded between 1 and 27 December 2020.

Question

"It is out of question to claim that this year there were many people who were not planned for and who caused congestion," Motsoaledi said.

Instead, trucking companies were to blame for the congestion as they decided to use the Beitbridge border post to avoid the Groblersbrug post on the Botswana border, because of the country's tight lockdown regulations and strict curfew.

"Many trucking companies found it unprofitable to cross into the region through Botswana. The SA border post with Botswana which is closest to Beitbridge is Groblersbrug. Usually, at this time of the year, Groblersbrug is used as an overflow area when Beitbridge cannot cope with the number of trucks. This year it was the other way round.

Trucks parked at Beit Bridge border post.
Trucks parked at the Beitbridge border post.
Gallo

"Trucking companies diverted their trucks away from Groblersbrug to Beitbridge because they did not accept the waiting times imposed by the Covid protocols in Botswana," Motsoaledi said.

The minister said this was evident by looking at the statistics.

READ | 4 truck drivers have died while queuing at the Beitbridge border post - RFA

In December 2019, 6 706 trucks went through Groblersbrug, compared to the 2 968 trucks that used the border post during December 2020.

"In contrast, 19 800 trucks went through Beitbridge in December 2019, compared to 21 800 by 27 December 2020.

"A simple analysis will show that Groblersbrug has 3 738 fewer trucks this year compared to 2019, and at least 2 000 of these trucks found their way to Beitbridge, hence the congestion."

In addition, truck drivers abandoned an arrangement that they park in holding areas or truck stops where they finalise a myriad of documents demanded by the South African Revenue Service and various trade protocols.

"By the time they leave the holding areas most of this administrative work will have been completed, which will result in a smooth transition at the border post.

"Unfortunately, these holding areas were abandoned and trucks parked on the road and even occupied lines of incoming traffic, consequently even blocking traffic from the Zimbabwean side heading into South Africa.

"It is not apportioning blame to truck companies when these facts are stated. They are just facts which are backed by figures. And we cannot spin them in any other way as the Freight Association of SA tried to in the past week. Indeed, facts are stubborn," Motsoaledi said.

Motsoaledi added that the holding areas have parking, water and ablution facilities.

"When you abandon the holding areas with all these facilities and park on the N1 and then blame the state for not providing water and ablution facilities, you are being disingenuous and dishonest."

"It is as if the adults who are in charge of the trucks are ordinary schoolboys with no responsibility of their own but who need to be shepherded all the time."

The minister did, however, concede that traffic officials were not present at the start of the congestion as it was not thought necessary because of the holding area arrangement.

He added that there was blame on both sides, but that the congestion would never have occurred if truck drivers had not left the holding areas.

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For only R75 per month, you have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today.
Subscribe to News24
Lockdown For
DAYS
HRS
MINS
Voting Booth
How has the delay in schools' opening impacted your life?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Results
It's a disaster! We're struggling to manage work and kids at home
41% - 1632 votes
It's a struggle, but we learnt lessons from last year's closures
19% - 773 votes
It's a relief, this second wave is bad and kids need to be at home
40% - 1585 votes
Vote
ZAR/USD
15.23
(-0.77)
ZAR/GBP
20.84
(-0.63)
ZAR/EUR
18.51
(-0.51)
ZAR/AUD
11.75
(-0.66)
ZAR/JPY
0.15
(-0.77)
Gold
1854.63
(-0.13)
Silver
25.31
(-0.86)
Platinum
1095.00
(-0.36)
Brent Crude
55.02
(0.00)
Palladium
2336.50
(-0.77)
All Share
64559.85
(+0.89)
Top 40
59408.05
(+0.89)
Financial 15
11549.82
(-1.16)
Industrial 25
88868.70
(+2.65)
Resource 10
62256.06
(-0.71)
All JSE data delayed by at least 15 minutes morningstar logo