WRAP | Gupta-linked Nulane trial adjourned until next week

Gupta brothers Atul, Rajesh and Ajay Gupta.
Gupta brothers Atul, Rajesh and Ajay Gupta.
Photo: Getty Images
Last Updated
Live News Feed
Go to start

27 January 12:30

We adjourn until next week.

27 January 12:29

Oldwadge wraps up, after accusing "someone" of "fiddling" with the documents attached to Stofile's statement. Hellens has no questions and the state does not want to re-examine Stofile.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 12:26

Oldwadge now suggests that the R12.4 million paid to Nulane was a "mobilisation payment". Stofile says he has not heard of this term, prompting scorn from Oldwadge. Stofile says different terms are used interchangeably and says that, if Oldwadge means an advance payment, he would agree.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 12:22

Stofile was called to begin the state's efforts to get financial documents related to Nulane admitted into evidence. He was not at the department at the time that the Nulane transactions happened. Oldwadge is however attempting to push him on the amounts invoiced and paid to Nulane and the circumstances that surrounded them.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 12:18

Oldwadge has spent some time questioning Stofile about how the alleged Nulane payments were defined and processed. He gets Stofile to confirm that Nulane was defined as a "non contract".

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 12:08

Oldwadge now moves on to Nulane's "commercial proposal", which he says was "amended". Stofile says he does not know the background of the report and cannot comment on whether it was amended or not.

Oldwadge now asks Stofile if he knew a certain department official who served as a deputy director of financial accounting.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 12:06

Oldwadge asks Stofile if the Nulane contracts appear to be dated 28 October 2011. Stofile agrees. Oldwadge then puts it to Stofile that he does not know who sent the Nulane invoices and how they arrived at the department. He agrees that he does not. (Patel is clearly attempting to distance himself from Nulane's activities).

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:59

Oldwadge wants Stofile to detail where he found the Nulane contracts. He responds that he found the contracts at the HoD's office.

Stofile confirms that documents in support of a payment are loaded, they are loaded at the finance department.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:56

Kenny Oldwadge, who is defending Sharma's brother-in-law and Nulane representative Dinesh Patel, is up next. He puts it to Stofile that he should be expected to have solid experience and expertise in supply chain management. Stofile agrees.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:53

Sharma's lawyer Bronwynne Forbay has no questions.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:53

Willem Edeling SC, who is representing former Free State Agriculture Department Chief Financial Officer Seipati Dhlamini, is asking Stofile if he found any payment confirmation documents. He responds that he did not find any.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:52

Ishmael Semenya SC, for former Free State agriculture department head Limakatso Moorosi, gets Stofile both to confirm that the Mohoma Mobung was a voted fund and to state that he cannot speak to the authenticity of the documents he has testified about. Semenya concludes.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:47

Mantsha points out that the state has previously led evidence that Nulane was paid R12.4 million on 6 October 2011 - the same day that the deviation was granted. Stofile has however made reference to financial documents that shows a R12.4 million payment to Nulane on 4 November 2011 at 18:23.

As yet, we have no explanation for the discrepancy.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:45

Mantsha also confirms that Thabethe signed Nulane's "commercial proposal summary" in his "official capacity".

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:41

Mantsha appears to be arguing that the invoice in question was for the final Nulane feasibility report, which he says was delivered on 12 March 2012.

He argues that someone in the department had to certify that services had been rendered. It was in this context that Mantsha signed the invoice, he says.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:41

Serunye concludes his questioning.

Daniel Mantsha, for Thabethe, tells Stofile that he needs to ask him questions about two documents: the first being the Nulane tax invoice allegedly signed by Thabethe.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:40

Stofile also makes reference to a final report for due diligence on selected projects identified by the Free State department of agriculture and rural development dated 12 March 2012. It is not clear whether this the report that Nulane was paid R24.9 million for - but logos for Deloitte, Nulane and the Free State government department appear on the front page.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:34

Stofile now refers to evidence that we haven't heard about before:

A "commercial proposal summary" by Nulane for the Mohoma Mobung project. It was signed in Sandton on 23 February 2012 - several months after Nulane had been paid R12.4 million by the department. The signatory on that document is Iqbal Sharma's brother-in-law and Nulane representative Dinesh Patel. Signing for the agriculture and rural development department on 2 March 2012 in Bloemfontein is Peter Thabethe, then Free State agriculture HoD.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:26

Stofile confirms that he found a "deviation submission to appoint Nulane" at the finance department. This is the deviation request that Cezula and Mahlangu previously gave evidence about.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:21

Acting judge Gusha provisionally admits the financial documentation read into the record by Stofile.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:19

Serunye now points out that another Nulane invoice - for over R8million - has different banking details on it. These details contain reference to a Bank of Baroda account. Bank of Baroda was used by members of the Gupta network previously implicated in the alleged Vrede Dairy Project scam.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:15

Important: Former Free State agriculture department head Peter Thabethe - who is also on trial for the alleged Vrede Dairy Farm scam - has sought to distance himself from the deviation request (that he signed) that enables Nulane to receive an expedited R12.4 million payment from the department.

The fact that he appears to have signed off on another R4 million payment for the company will be used by the state to attack that defence.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:11

Stofile refers to a 7 December 2011 invoice from Nulane Investments to the department for R4.16 million. As Serunye displays these invoices on a screen, Stofile reads out the dates, amounts and bank details written on them. 

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:09

State advocate Peter Serunye takes Stofile through the payments made by the Free State agriculture department to Nulane.

(Photo: Karyn Maughan)

<p>State advocate Peter Serunye takes Stofile through the payments made by the Free State agriculture department to Nulane.</p><p>(Photo: Karyn Maughan)</p>

27 January 11:05

Stofile is taking the court through various payment stubs, which record payments made by the department to Nulane between 2011 and 2012.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 11:04

The state’s third witness, Avelamadoda Stofile, a former Free State agriculture department director called to testify about Nulane documents seized by the Hawks.

(Photo: Karyn Maughan) 

<p>The state’s third witness, Avelamadoda Stofile, a former Free State agriculture department director called to testify about Nulane documents seized by the Hawks.</p><p><em>(Photo: Karyn Maughan)&nbsp;</em></p>

27 January 11:03

Stofile is now reading out the first Nulane invoice, which is dated in December 2011 and for an amount of R4 million. The second is for 12 March 2012, for an amount of R8.3 million. Unlike the first invoice, the second is signed, allegedly with Thabethe's signature.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 10:56

Stofile testifies that he found invoices from Nulane. These invoices had certain documents attached to them, which he says were necessary to process payment. He says he thinks he found two invoices and two system printouts.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 10:55

Stofile now reads out the title of the department's contract with Nulane. It is provisionally admitted as evidence - pending the testimony of the official who had it.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 10:51


This testimony is clearly intended by the state to address complaints from the defense that the authenticity of certain of the documents it is relying on as evidence has not been proven.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 10:49

Stofile says he found a copy of the contract and the Nulane feasibility study report at the HoD's office.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 10:46

Stofille says he initially could not find the documents sought by the police in the supply chain management department and sought help from the head of department, who asked the department's Chief Financial Officer for help. Stofile says he managed to find some payment documents in the finance department and relied on a system print out to track down others.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 10:43

Stofile was a director of supply chain management at the Free State agriculture department after the alleged Nulane fraud took place. He was present, however, when the Hawks conducted a search and seizure raid on the office.

Stofile says he assisted the police in tracking down various tender documents and documents related to Nulane payments.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 10:41

Defence advocate Kenny Oldwadge, who this morning successfully argued for a postponement of the testimony of former Deloitte employee Thomas Church.

(Photo: Karyn Maughan) 

<p>Defence advocate Kenny Oldwadge, who this morning successfully argued for a postponement of the testimony of former Deloitte employee Thomas Church.</p><p><em>(Photo: Karyn Maughan)&nbsp;</em></p>

27 January 10:40

Nulane accused Iqbal Sharma talks to his lawyer during the break. 

(Photo:Karyn Maughan) 

<p>Nulane accused Iqbal Sharma talks to his lawyer during the break.&nbsp;</p><p><em>(Photo:Karyn Maughan)&nbsp;</em></p>

27 January 10:39

The trial resumes. The state calls former Free State agriculture department director Avelamadoda Stofile.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 10:05

We are breaking until 10:30 so that the state can call another witness.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 09:59

Serunye says the postponement application by the defence is "fair" and stresses that the draft report only became available to the state yesterday. He denies that the state is seeking to ambush the defence. Serunye proposes that the state will call another witness while the defense prepares to deal with the Deloitte draft report.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 09:56

Lawyer Bronwynne Forbay, who is representing former Transnet Board member and Gupta ally Iqbal Sharma, who owns Nulane, supports Oldwadge's argument and reiterates that his client also wishes to forensically examine Church's iPad.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 09:54

Oldwadge says the state's "flimsy" excuse for providing that draft report now was that Church only recently found the draft report.

He accuses the state of "impeding" his client's "rights to a fair trial" and says the defence should be given an opportunity to study the report - and given an opportunity to forensically examine Church's iPad.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 09:50

Oldwadge says Serunye volunteered that the relevance of this draft report was that it could show that "someone" made certain changes to the draft report before it was provided to the agriculture department. He says it was "alarming" that the draft report was only provided to the defence yesterday, because Church made reference to it in March 2021.

"I will not voluntarily walk into an ambush," Oldwadge says.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 09:47

Oldwadge says his application is a consequence of what happened after the trial adjourned yesterday and the defence was approached by Serunye. He says the prosecutor handed him a copy of a draft Deloitte report, the contents of which he declines to detail.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 09:45

Prosecutor Peter Serunye tells acting judge Nompumelelo Gusha that the state intended to call Church, but says Oldwadge wishes to "make an application before we proceed".

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 09:43

Court has resumed.

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 09:42

We are back on the Free State High Court in Bloemfontein this morning, where a big battle is brewing over evidence that was provided to the defence yesterday - in connection with testimony that is supposed to be given by Thomas Church, a former employee at Deloitte.

He is being called to testify about how Nulane Investments allegedly changed a draft feasibility study on the Mohoma Mobung initiative to identify Paras – an Indian dairy farm allegedly linked to the Guptas – as the most suitable implementing partner for setting up a milk processing plant in Vrede, Free State.

This, the state claims, enabled the Vrede Dairy farm scam, which looted millions intended for poor black farmers. The state yesterday provided the defence with the Deloitte draft report (pre alleged Nulane changes) and advocate Kenny Oldwadge, for Nulane Investments representative Dinesh Patel, is expected to argue that this amounts to an "ambush".

It is expected that Oldwadge may ask for a postponement so that the defence can examine the report

- Karyn Maughan 

27 January 07:32

'You shouldn't be a 204 witness': Defence lawyers argue Nulane whistleblower exposed no crime

- The NPA's first state capture trial began this week, in which former government officials and Gupta associates are being tried in connection with the alleged R24.9 million Nulane fraud.

- It is the State's case that the Free State agriculture department paid R24.9 million to Nulane Investment for a fraudulent feasibility study.

- Free State agriculture department official Shadrack Cezula testified that he was placed under "unbearable" pressure to ensure that Nulane received a R12.4 million payment from the department.


26 January 15:58

Cezula is excused. We adjourn until 09:30 tomorrow.

- Karyn Maughan

26 January 15:56

Oldwadge asks for an opportunity to ask Cezula if he was aware that some work related to the Nulane contract had already been done (by Deloitte) in September 2011, prior to Nulane being paid, as a result of the deviation.

- Karyn Maughan

26 January 15:51

Cezula says Dhlamini's claims that she did not dictate the deviation application to him are "incorrect". 

- Karyn Maughan

26 January 15:44

In response to questions from Serunye about the different commissioning on his statement, Cezula confirms that these differences in how these statements were commissioned were the only ones that existed. The statements were exactly the same, he says.

- Karyn Maughan

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For 14 free days, you can have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today. Thereafter you will be billed R75 per month. You can cancel anytime and if you cancel within 14 days you won't be billed. 
Subscribe to News24
Voting Booth
What are your thoughts on the possibility of having permanent Stage 2 or 3 load shedding?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
I'll take that over constant schedule changes
13% - 571 votes
Why are we normalising Eskom’s mess?
72% - 3178 votes
I've already found alternative ways of powering my home/business
15% - 642 votes
Rand - Dollar
Rand - Pound
Rand - Euro
Rand - Aus dollar
Rand - Yen
Brent Crude
Top 40
All Share
Resource 10
Industrial 25
Financial 15
All JSE data delayed by at least 15 minutes Iress logo
Editorial feedback and complaints

Contact the public editor with feedback for our journalists, complaints, queries or suggestions about articles on News24.