Lockdown: Sakeliga threatens legal action against DTI and minister Patel over cooked food ban

Business group Sakeliga has threatened legal action against the Department of Trade and Industry unless Minister Ebrahim Patel reverses his recently announced restriction on warm or cooked foods. 

"We have been advised that there is no lawful restriction on the production of 'warm', 'cooked' or 'prepared' food as the minister and his department continues to insist," Sakeliga CEO Piet le Roux said in a statement.

"Sakeliga will be taking the Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition to court unless he ceases and reverses his department’s unlawful, irrational, and harmful obstructions to food production."

The group has given Patel until 09:00 on Monday to respond or they will take legal action.

Le Roux said their legal advice went against what the department and Patel had said. 

"We have also been advised by senior counsel that there is no lawful basis on which the [Companies and Intellectual Property Commission] can certify whether products and services are essential or not.

Le Roux rejected Patel's announcement.  

"Officials keep issuing these arbitrary directives in press statements and tweets, but nothing of the sort has been promulgated. The DTI’s attempts to legislate by mere pronouncement are, irrespective of the merits of its instructions, a danger to the rule of law. Even in the face of our unusual circumstances, the principles of constitutionality and legality must be followed."

No replies

He also said that every food item on a shop shelf was already prepared in some way. He added that it would be impossible to comply, and would decrease food supply and increase prices.

The Sakeliga group also said it had tried to discuss the issue with the ministry, but didn't receive replies to its overtures, hence the threat of court action. 

Woolworths have since responded to the action.

UPDATE: Woolworths to close hot food counters, despite legal opinion

A legal opinion also did the rounds on Twitter, which labelled the DTI announcement illegal.

One of its points reads: "There is no other provision in the lockdown regulation which prohibits the sale of any category of food."

On its Facebook page, the store - which has become popular during lockdown for its prepared deli items - wrote that it was still seeking clarity on this issue, an outlet near News24 had a sign up saying its hot food section was closed. 

 

Woolworths

A sign at a Woolworths hot food counter in Cape Town (News24)


The popular brand said: "While this has not yet been formally promulgated in the regulations, and we are seeking clarity on the way forward, we have taken a decision to close all hot food counters with immediate effect to adhere to the communication ...

"We have been trading our hot food counters as both our interpretation of the regulations and that of our external legal counsel permitted this. However, it appears that the regulations will be further updated to expressly prohibit foods retailers from trading hot foods counters within their stores."

Seeking legal advice

DA Member of Parliament Dean Macpherson submitted a letter to Patel and the department, asking how the rationale for the legal advice was determined. He demanded answers by 17:00 on Sunday. 

Macpherson said he believed it would be devastating for essential service workers who rely on take-away food, and the elderly who are not unable to cook their own food anymore. 

International trade attorney Rian Geldenhuys said the regulations were not always crystal clear. 

In the case of shops selling cooked food, Geldenhuys said these counters could be interpreted as falling under the category of being a restaurant, which are not allowed to operate during the lockdown, "because they could be considered as gathering places".

He said businesses in this situation were seeking legal advice on which to base their decisions to consider operating, "or whether to close completely".

A sector of the cigarette manufacturing industry is also planning a court challenge over the right to sell cigarettes during the lockdown. A liquor consortium has decided to hold of on their own possible action pending further information from  President Cyril Ramaphosa. 

Lockdown For
DAYS
HRS
MINS
Voting Booth
South Africa has over 150 000 Covid-19 cases. Do you know someone who has been infected?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Results
Yes I do
27% - 3655 votes
Yes, more than one person
24% - 3320 votes
No I don't
49% - 6608 votes
Vote
ZAR/USD
17.00
(-0.09)
ZAR/GBP
21.24
(-0.12)
ZAR/EUR
19.14
(-0.13)
ZAR/AUD
11.81
(-0.13)
ZAR/JPY
0.16
(-0.20)
Gold
1774.74
(+0.03)
Silver
18.05
(+0.01)
Platinum
808.00
(+0.25)
Brent Crude
42.78
(-0.79)
Palladium
1914.01
(+0.62)
All Share
54521.90
(-0.17)
Top 40
50179.89
(-0.26)
Financial 15
10150.02
(-0.64)
Industrial 25
76554.73
(+0.52)
Resource 10
50138.02
(-1.24)
All JSE data delayed by at least 15 minutes morningstar logo