How Clinton's and Trump's economic prescriptions clash

Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton and Republican presidential front runner Donald Trump. (Joe Raedle & Spencer Platt, AFP)
Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton and Republican presidential front runner Donald Trump. (Joe Raedle & Spencer Platt, AFP)

Washington - Republican Donald Trump will deliver a speech outlining his trade policies on Tuesday - a talk that is sure to underscore the stark differences between his approach and that of likely Democratic rival Hillary Clinton when it comes to handling the economy.

Trump favours big tax cuts that mainly would help the rich. Clinton wants to boost taxes on high earners.

Clinton wants to raise the minimum wage nationwide. Trump favours leaving it to the states.

Trump sees a middle class crushed by trade deals, globalisation and shameless corporations moving jobs overseas.

Clinton argues that rebuilding the middle class requires government aid for higher education and job training. She wants to push corporations to share profits and raise pay.

The two candidates sketched out their duelling economic visions in speeches last week that highlighted their clashing ideas for energising growth and hiring.

Trump all talk

Some similarities between the two emerged as well, easily overlooked amid the back-and-forth. Both laced their speeches with populist attacks on Wall Street and descriptions of the economy as "rigged", though Trump, aiming to draw supporters of Democratic candidate Bernie Sanders, did so more than Clinton.

Both also stressed the need for more widely shared prosperity, a nod to the notion that economic growth since the end of the Great Recession has served mainly wealthier households and a handful of dynamic cities.

Overall, Clinton has made many more specific proposals than Trump, who has yet to spell out plans in such key areas as education, job training or the rebuilding of roads, bridges and other infrastructure.

He spoke of building "the greatest infrastructure on the planet earth" but hasn't laid out how he would do so.

Many of Clinton's plans - raising taxes on wealthier households and boosting financial aid for education and job training - resemble President Barack Obama's and, economists say, largely reflect the status quo.

"The Clinton plan is very much in line with Obama's campaign proposals and the budgets he has proposed as president," said Josh Bivens, research and policy director for the liberal Economic Policy Institute.

Most economists have been dismissive of Trump's economic proposals, particularly his steep tax cuts.

"The Trump plan is just this enormous tax cut that couldn't be adopted," said Alan Auerbach, an economics professor at the University of California, Berkeley and a leading expert on tax and budget policy. "I don't even know to evaluate it."

Some highlights of the candidates' economic proposals:


CLINTON: Says she opposes the Trans-Pacific Partnership trade agreement with 11 other nations along the Pacific Rim. She had endorsed the pact when she was secretary of state. She pledges to step up enforcement of trade laws that can be used to bar low-priced imports by creating a chief trade prosecutor and tripling the number of trade enforcement officers.

TRUMP: Opposes the Trans-Pacific Partnership accord. Has threatened to impose a 45% tariff on Chinese imports in retaliation for Beijing's currency manipulation. He also would impose a 35% tariff on imports from Mexico to discourage US companies from moving there. He'll deliver a speech on the topic on Tuesday, which his team has titled "Declaring American Economic Independence" at Alumisource, a factory in Monessen, Pennsylvania, about an hour south of Pittsburgh,


TRUMP: Proposes huge across-the-board tax cuts that would mostly benefit wealthier Americans. He would replace seven current tax rates with three. The top tax rate would be 25%, down from 39.6%. The two other rates would be 10% and 20%. Taxes on dividends and capital gains would be capped at 20%. He would eliminate the tax on large estates.

CLINTON: Supports large tax increases on wealthier Americans. She would add a 4% tax surcharge on incomes above $5 million, effectively creating a new top bracket of 43.6%. Those earning above $1 million a year would be subject to a minimum 30% income tax. She would also reduce the value of tax deductions and exemptions for wealthy taxpayers. And she would increase the estate tax.


TRUMP: During the primaries, he supported keeping the federal minimum wage at $7.25 an hour. But in May, he changed his position and said it should be higher. Has not specified a minimum wage and said it should be left up to states.

CLINTON: Supports a $12-an-hour federal minimum wage and "state and local efforts" to raise the minimum to $15.


CLINTON: Proposes spending $275bn on repairing and building roads and bridges, expanding public transportation and increasing high-speed internet access. Of that amount, $250bn would be spent directly on infrastructure over five years. Would also create a $25bn infrastructure bank that would be independent but government-owned and would offer loans and other financial aid for infrastructure projects.

TRUMP: Hasn't proposed specific plans but says, if he's elected: "We will build the greatest infrastructure on the planet Earth."

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For only R75 per month, you have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today.
Subscribe to News24
Lockdown For
Voting Booth
When assisting your child with remote learning this year, did you:
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Follow the school's comprehensive sexuality education (CSE) curriculum?
13% - 201 votes
Adjust the CSE curriculum to suit the family's morals?
24% - 358 votes
Ignore the schools CSE programme and do your own teaching?
63% - 942 votes
Brent Crude
All Share
Top 40
Financial 15
Industrial 25
Resource 10
All JSE data delayed by at least 15 minutes morningstar logo