Judge Boks after England series!

Mark Keohane (File)
Mark Keohane (File)

A judgement on the Springboks will only be made once the English three-Test series against England is completed, but what the one-off Test against Wales emphasised was that the depth of international talent in this country does not match the hype.

There is an inflated sense of description when it comes to many of players spoken of as Springboks.

Bok coach Rassie Erasmus blooded 13 new Springboks against Wales. He had two training sessions with the team, while also working with a different starting XV that will play England in Johannesburg this Saturday.

There must be perspective in what has transpired in the build-up to the opening two Tests. The England performance is where the Boks and Erasmus’s immediate impact will be measured. He would have had two weeks with the squad, it will be a home game and it will be the 23 players he deems to be the strongest available.

The match against Wales reminded me of those so many awful Springbok midweek performances in years gone by. The international schedule these days doesn’t allow for Springbok midweek games, but the team picked to play Wales, and the nature of the game was so akin to everything that is unfashionable about these types of matches.

The ‘dirt trackers’, as the second stringers are affectionately referred to, are invariably a mixture of kids and oldies who were hardened first class players but never quite good enough to regularly play Test rugby.

The Boks against Wales had very few hardened first-class players and many youngsters. There was a sprinkling of Test quality stars, with the obvious one being Stormers loosehead prop Steven Kitshoff, who is world class.

Kitshoff is one of the best in the business, whether he starts or provides impact off the bench. He has for some time been the in-form prop in South African rugby and this season has been one of the best in Super Rugby.

Kitshoff was in a different class to Ox Nche, who made his debut against Wales. Nche is a talented young player but his conditioning was shown up and also his inexperience. His work-rate was not of Test match standard and he now knows what he has to do to get back into the Springboks mix. Currently, he isn’t there.

What the match highlighted for me was how many players are not quite there yet when it comes to Test rugby. Wales were as inexperienced and the line-up that played the Boks also was of the dirt tracker variety.

However, the mental pressures and the emotional demands of knowing it was a Test match is what the respective coaches would have evaluated.

And it’s here where many players were floored.

The most surprising implosion came from reserve flyhalf Robert du Preez. I rate Du Preez highly and I am sure he will still enjoy a productive and inspiring international career, but it couldn’t have gone worse for him in those final two minutes. He had two kicks charged down, the second of which led to the Welsh match winning try. He threw what looked like a forward pass and then also through one wobbly one that Jesse Kriel did well to gather. Du Preez’s debut was simply messy.

The big disappointments for me came in the starting pack. Oupa Mohoje’s decision-making and appreciation of the laws at the breakdown was poor, and in instances he just seemed lazy in his execution. Nche was just off the pace, Kwagga Smith was industrious but he could be a case of too good for the second team but just not good enough for the first team. Jason Jenkins is not Test quality and Wilco Louw’s work-rate has to improve. Dan du Preez was inconsistent and made a few basic howlers.

Ivan van Zyl at scrumhalf has the attributes to provide a strong kicking game, but his accuracy was off and his predictability required absolute precision in where he landed his box kicks. A poor box kick simply gives the ball away, and the Boks in the opening 40 minutes simply gave away the ball.

The Test would have been a feast for the anti Elton Jantjies and Jesse Kriel gallery. The duo did themselves no favours. They were poor.

Both wingers were enthusiastic but their inexperience as a duo and as a back three unit was also shown up.

It is why Willie le Roux will start at fullback against England. Curwin Bosch was indecisive and Warrick Gelant was equally inconsistent in his application of when to run and kick. Gelant’s attacking enthusiasm won’t be curbed but he needs to have a greater regard for field position and the consequence when playing just off instinct in his own half.

Andre Esterhuizen (at inside centre) was the surprise package for me. He looked like an imposing Test player.

Kitshoff was huge and Marvin Orie added X-factor when replacing Jenkins at lock. Ambrose Papier’s athleticism was again evident.

But on the evidence of Washington DC, only a handful of players will feature against England and, of those, only Kitshoff could claim to be good enough to start.

That’s the perspective from the first up defeat. It’s not an excuse but a reality that many of those who travelled to the USA won’t be travelling to Bloemfontein and Cape Town for the final two Tests of the England series.

What the Welsh Test showed emphatically is that South Africa’s current Test player pool is closer to 25 than 42.

Mark Keohane is a Cape-Town based award-winning rugby specialist and former Springbok Communications Manager. Follow him on Twitter 

Disclaimer: Sport24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on Sport24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Sport24.

Previous Mark Keohane columns on Sport24:

Boks can pick 2 teams of equal strength

Why Kolisi is the best option to lead Boks

Louw’s Bok credentials soar after Newlands derby

Newlands derby is D-Day for Springbok contenders

Kolisi needs to up his game

'X-factor' RG Snyman deserves Bok call

There is enough quality for Boks to excel in 2018

Is SANZAAR waiting for the death of a player?

Bok series will be the end of Eddie Jones

Don't blame transformation for SA rugby woes

Stormers don't have halfbacks to challenge in Super Rugby

Bulls will be a different animal under Mitchell

Back Sharks to be SA's top team

Rassie's Boks will beat England's Eddie

Shocking results, not race behind Coetzee's axing

No tournament with Sunwolves can be 'best v best'!

How Rassie plans to re-align SA Rugby

Scrap the 30-Test ruling and make Cheslin Kolbe a Bok!

Blitzboks, not All Blacks, the talk of Cape Town

Kids don't win RWCs, get back Duane, Frans!

Why Rassie is the man to take Boks forward

Paris glory won't erase Albany and Dublin gore

I'd happily take a 1-point win!

To vote against SA's bid would be an insult

Bosch will win Currie Cup final for Sharks

No current Bok would make 2007 team!

Dublin is D-Day for Boks

All Blacks' lack of desire gives Boks a sniff

Boks will beat Wallabies, but...

Bok changes won't spell panic

Boks will run All Blacks close

Win or lose in Perth, Boks have made progress!

Etzebeth is the right choice for Bok captain!

Kriel sets example others should follow

Combrinck to lead Lions to Super Rugby title

Jantjies the man to lead Lions to glory

Stormers WILL reach Super Rugby semis!

Stormers need to back youngster Willemse

Serfontein, Mostert the Boks standouts

Boks must extend Brendan 'Mr Fixit' Venter's role

Coetzee's Lions-laden Bok side can't lose!

Expect a different looking Bok starting XV!

Fear not, Boks will whitewash France 3-0!

Hey Allister, load the Boks with Lions!

The RWC 2019 gods have smiled on the Boks!

Unleash Curwin Bosch on the French!

YES, an overseas-based SA team would beat the Boks, but...

The next Springbok skipper has to be...

Super Rugby cull good for SA rugby

Clap, clap ... Venter's appointment should be applauded

South African rugby NEEDS to host RWC 2023

Why SA can't have 6 Super Rugby teams

Super 12 glory is now Super 18 gory

No winner is SARU's half-cocked overseas policy

Keeping Coetzee sadly no April Fools' joke

Mediocrity must fall!

Overseas based SA players are no traitors!

Sick Boks need more than a new doctor

Joost earned more than a minute's silence

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For only R75 per month, you have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today.
Subscribe to News24
loading... Live
India 325/10 & 69/0
New Zealand 62/10
Voting Booth
What are your views on the World Rugby men's Player of the Year nominations for 2021 not including any Springboks?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
It's a disgrace! Both Siya Kolisi AND Eben Etzebeth should have been nominated!
39% - 5542 votes
Siya, at the very least, should have been included after a superb season
7% - 936 votes
Etzebeth has been SA's best player this year and should feel hard done by
20% - 2886 votes
Get over it! Moaning about this just sounds like sour grapes!
34% - 4724 votes