Genia's benching 'baffling'

Will Genia (Getty Images)
Will Genia (Getty Images)

Melbourne - Australia scrumhalf Will Genia freely gave Nic White a couple of pairs of leftover boots to wear but is unlikely to have handed over his No 9 shirt quite so willingly to his understudy ahead of Saturday's match against Argentina.

Wallabies coach Ewen McKenzie confirmed on Wednesday that 25-year-old Genia, regarded one of the game's finest scrumhalves, will cool his heels on the bench for the Perth match against the Pumas as penance for an indifferent start to the southern hemisphere Rugby Championship.

McKenzie, himself under pressure after three straight losses to open his tenure, cast the stunning decision as a wake-up call for his most dangerous and creative player who, in any case, would be sure to 'bounce back'.

The demotion has polarised Australia's rugby community, who have been sorely disappointed by McKenzie's failure to produce a winning team in the two months since taking over from Robbie Deans.

"When you drop your only world XV quality player to the bench, you would want a long list of very good reasons to justify it," respected rugby writer Greg Growden fumed in a column on ESPN Scrum.

"Genia's axing is baffling and dangerous, especially as Argentina is a far better team than what many in Australia think."

In dropping Genia, McKenzie has at least been true to his word, that reputations count for little in his selections.

Genia's brilliance with the Reds under his head coach McKenzie helped secure the Brisbane-based team its maiden title in Super Rugby in 2011.

Barring a serious knee injury that sidelined Genia for much of last season, the pint-sized playmaker has owned the No 9 jersey for the past four years, a reassuring presence for Wallabies fans and team-mates alike, and a bulwark of stability in a backline seemingly always in flux.

The last time Genia played off the bench - he was rested - the Wallabies were upset on home soil by lowly Samoa in 2011.

Genia showed flashes of brilliance in the lost series to the British and Irish Lions, winning man-of-the-match in the second of three Tests, despite carrying a knee injury.

He has struggled to make an impact in two opening defeats to New Zealand and Saturday's calamitous 38-12 loss to South Africa, but has hardly been alone, with team-mates belted across the field.

As the only change to the Wallabies backline, however, Genia appears to be the sacrificial lamb.

Bob Dwyer, who coached Australia to their maiden Rugby World Cup triumph in 1991, said he had nonetheless contributed to a "pathetically slow" attack in McKenzie's new regime.

"I see absolutely below-standard performance in terms of a his role as the scrumhalf," Dwyer said.

"He can run and do all those things, he's courageous, he's a good tackler, he does get back and collect the high ball frequently but they're add-ons.

"If you can do the fundamentals of your role well, and you can do the add-ons great, but if you can't do the fundamentals well, then it doesn't matter...

"Because the fundamentals of your position affect everyone else on the field, in this case negatively."

The promotion of White, whose international experience has consisted of three runs off the bench in the Rugby Championship, will place huge pressure on the 23-year-old and his halfback partner Quade Cooper, who failed to make an impact against the Springboks at Lang Park.

Putting aside his disappointment, Genia has given White a few pointers ahead of his maiden start.

"He's not only offered advice, he's also given me two pairs of boots," White, who wears the same size as Genia, told reporters in Perth.

White enjoyed a breakout season for Super Rugby's Brumbies this year, and Dwyer suggested the speedy halfback might be able to fill Genia's shoes in a more literal sense.

"Interestingly on Saturday, the only positive attacking plays of the game by Australia came towards the end of the game was when (White) was scrumhalf," he said.



15 Israel Folau, 14 James O'Connor, 13 Adam Ashley-Cooper, 12 Christian Leali'ifano, 11 Nick Cummins, 10 Quade Cooper, 9 Nic White, 8 Ben Mowen (captain), 7 Michael Hooper, 6 Scott Fardy, 5 Kane Douglas, 4 Rob Simmons, 3 Ben Alexander, 2 Stephen Moore, 1 James Slipper.

Substitutes: 16 Saia Fainga'a, 17 Scott Sio, 18 Sekope Kepu, 19 Sitaleki Timani, 20 Ben McCalman, 21 Will Genia, 22 Matt Toomua, 23 Tevita Kuridrani


15 Juan Martin Hernandez, 14 Horacio Agulla, 13 Gonzalo Tiesi, 12  Felipe Contepomi, 11 Juan Imhoff, 10 Nicolas Sanchez, 9 Tomas Cubelli, 8 Juan Manuel Leguizamon, 7 Pablo Matera, 6 Juan Martin Fernandez Lobbe (captain), 5 Julio Farias Cabello, 4 Manuel Carizza, 3 Juan Figallo, 2 Agustin Creevy, 1 Marcos Ayerza

Substitutes: 16 Eusebio Guinazu, 17 Nahuel Lobo, 18 Juan Pablo Orlandi, 19 Mariano Galarza, 20 Benjamin Macome, 21 Martin Landajo, 22 Santiago Fernandez, 23 Lucas Gonzalez Amorosino

Voting Booth
What is your favourite sport to watch on TV?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
42% - 7911 votes
11% - 1977 votes
19% - 3610 votes
2% - 464 votes
1% - 172 votes
2% - 444 votes
5% - 923 votes
8% - 1572 votes
3% - 628 votes
Water sports
1% - 168 votes
American sports
1% - 220 votes
3% - 573 votes