Clive Woodward slams Jaco Peyper's Six Nations red card: 'One of the worst decisions I've seen'

play article
Subscribers can listen to this article
SA referee Jaco Peyper talks to Freddie Steward before showing him a red card in the Six Nations match between Ireland and England in Dublin on 18 March 2023. (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)
SA referee Jaco Peyper talks to Freddie Steward before showing him a red card in the Six Nations match between Ireland and England in Dublin on 18 March 2023. (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)
  • Former England coach Clive Woodward has slammed Jaco Peyper's decision to red card Freddie Steward in a Six Nations game. 
  • The red card has since been downgraded to yellow but Woodward feels no card was warranted.
  • The 2003 World Cup-winning coach called on officials to "have an empathy for the game and make decisions accordingly". 

Rugby World Cup-winning coach Clive Woodward says the decision to red card England fullback Freddie Steward in a Six Nations match against Ireland was "one of the worst" decisions he's ever seen in the sport.

Steward was controversially sent off by South African referee Jaco Peyper after he made head contact with Ireland counterpart Hugo Keenan.

Steward and Keenan had both charged towards a loose ball. The England fullback braced for contact as Keenan looked to scoop up the ball, before the players made contact.

Peyper deemed Steward's actions were reckless and dished out a red card.

A Six Nations disciplinary panel confirmed on Wednesday that the red card should have instead been a yellow

However, Woodward said the incident left a blemish on the sport.

"When Jaco Peyper and his fellow officials decided Steward should be sent off in Dublin, the words used were that his collision with Keenan was a sending off in the 'current climate'. What on earth does that mean?" Woodward wrote in his Daily Mail column.

"The only 'current climate' to the sport is that it is in meltdown. The officials are working off a tick sheet when it comes to making big decisions and they are all terrified of making the wrong call or doing something to upset World Rugby which will affect their careers. That sums up the game as a whole at the moment."

Woodward said initially he agreed that a yellow card was the appropriate sanction, but he has since had a change of heart.

"I don't think there should have been any card at all. The decision to show Steward red was one of the worst I've seen. I agree with a lot of what my fellow Sportsmail columnist Shaun Edwards has said on this issue. But I don't feel sorry for the referees. They are being told to operate within the laws, but they should not be accountable to World Rugby. They should be accountable to the sport.

"We all respect and admire the referees. We have no game without them. But no law is black and white. A referee has to interpret them and the Steward incident was a classic example of failing to do that. I was hugely surprised no-one from the RFU came out and defended Steward. 

"Officials need to have an empathy for the game and make decisions accordingly. Anyone with rugby knowledge or experience knows the Steward-Keenan contact was what we would call a 'rugby incident'. There was no intent or malice from either player."

Woodward further questioned what else Steward could have done in that scenario.

"He told Peyper at the time: 'I'm bracing for impact and I can't go anywhere else. 'It's milliseconds. I can't react quickly enough.' He is spot on. Rugby needs to eradicate these mistakes now. We can't have a repeat of the Steward scenario at big tournament games in France later this year."

The Six Nations panel determined Steward "had been reckless in his actions and in his upright positioning as he approached and came into highly dangerous contact with the other player". However, mitigation applied "including the late change in the dynamics and positioning of the opposing player".

Steward will not serve any ban and is free to play with immediate effect. His escape, however, is too late for England as they lost the Six Nations game 29-16 in Dublin.

The panel also acknowledged that match officials are required to make "decisions under pressure and in the heat of a live match environment".

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For 14 free days, you can have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today. Thereafter you will be billed R75 per month. You can cancel anytime and if you cancel within 14 days you won't be billed. 
Subscribe to News24
Show Comments ()
loading... Live
Southampton 0
Liverpool 1
loading... Live
Manchester United 0
Fulham 0
loading... Live
Leicester City 0
West Ham United 0
loading... Live
Leeds United 0
Tottenham 1
loading... Live
Everton 0
AFC Bournemouth 0
loading... Live
Crystal Palace 0
Nottingham Forest 0
loading... Live
Chelsea 0
Newcastle United 1
loading... Live
Brentford 0
Manchester City 0
loading... Live
Aston Villa 1
Brighton and Hove Albion 0
loading... Live
Arsenal 2
Wolverhampton Wanderers 0
Voting Booth
Who should replace Jacques Nienaber as Springbok coach after the 2023 Rugby World Cup?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Deon Davids
2% - 128 votes
Mzwandile Stick
6% - 311 votes
John Dobson
19% - 996 votes
Johan Ackermann
23% - 1178 votes
Franco Smith
5% - 268 votes
Johann van Graan
3% - 181 votes
Jake White
7% - 366 votes
Rassie Erasmus
34% - 1758 votes
Editorial feedback and complaints

Contact the public editor with feedback for our journalists, complaints, queries or suggestions about articles on News24.