Refs should deal with player dissent 'in the harshest way' - URC referees boss Tappe Henning

play article
Subscribers can listen to this article
Bundee Aki receives a red card against the Stormers. (Photo by Ashley Vlotman/Gallo Images)
Bundee Aki receives a red card against the Stormers. (Photo by Ashley Vlotman/Gallo Images)
  • URC referees’ boss Tappe Henning says referees should deal harshly with any forms of dissent, such as Bandee Aki’s in the Stormers clash with Connacht.
  • The Ireland international centre was red-carded for a dangerous clean out against Stormers wing Seabelo Senatla.
  • Aki then remonstrated with Italian official Gianluca Gnecchi, whom Henning lauded for maintaining his composure.

United Rugby Championship (URC) referees’ boss Tappe Henning says referees should deal harshly with any forms of dissent that can bring the game into disrepute.

Henning was on a URC round table discussing matters regarding match officials when he was asked about the incident regarding Connacht centre Bundee Aki last weekend, when the Ireland international was red-carded for a dangerous clean out against Stormers wing Seabelo Senatla.

Aki proceeded to vociferously argue with the referee in an incident that has been widely condemned by pundits.

READ | Aki 'extremely apologetic' after seeing red against Stormers

Henning praised Italian referee Gianluca Gnecchi for how he handled the incident, which could have become more emotional.

“Referees understand that players believe they are correct in their execution and what they want to do,” said Henning, the URC head of match officials.

“Players understand that, if the referee deems something is a red-card offence, it has a huge impact on their team and they are emotional. In those situations, you don’t need referees to overact.

“If it exceeds the limit and starts becoming directed at the match officials, accusing them of incompetence or directly aiming at the ability of the referee and their decision-making, we expect the referees to draw the line and say: ‘Bundee, we’ve had enough. I know you’re disappointed’.

“I thought Gianluca was very smart in how he said, ‘I explained’ and asked the captain to deal with the player, just to diffuse the situation.

“If it gets worse than that then the referee will definitely act. I’m pretty sure that in the disciplinary process, I’ve seen many times how the disciplinary hearing makes mention of the player accepting the decision of the match official on the day.

“In this case, I’m pretty sure that the disciplinary hearing will probably give its attention to that. I don’t want to say what they should do but I’ve seen examples where it was addressed.

“It comes into consideration when the sanction is being reached.”

Henning added that such behaviour can certainly influence the sanction handed down by a disciplinary committee to a player.

“Players know that poor behaviour towards the match official when such a big decision is being made can lead to a different sanction in terms of weeks.

“To sum up, we don’t want referees to overreact when they realise the player with adrenaline in the heat of the moment says something that two minutes later he’ll be sorry about.

“I’m pretty sure Bundee, when he was back in his seat, was saying, ‘Actually I am in trouble here’.

“At that moment, he would have defended [it] with his life because he’s part of a team and realises he’s let his team down [and then] he tries to defend it.

“If we sense it is becoming a problem, we’ll send out a message to the clubs first that match officials will not tolerate it and it’s a club problem. If it comes on to the field, we as match officials will deal with it in the harshest way.”

Henning also announced several changes to the way officials will handle the season, including:
  • The URC’s referee panel now stands at 20, with three development referees added to the panel.
  • URC Referees will continue to be appointed to the TMO role in order to upskill them and create greater consistency in decision-making processes.
  • The referee and the TMO are pairing regularly to enhance teamwork and consistency in the TMO process & decisions. Pairings may also swap roles, with one official refereeing on a Friday night and then doing TMO on Saturday.
  • Independent Selectors Panel of four retired international referees to refresh performance review process and appoint and select URC Elite Match Official Panel, namely Nigel Owens (Wales), George Clancy (Ireland), Stuart Berry (South Africa), Neil Paterson (Scotland).
  • URC Match Official Set-Piece Coach (Stevie Scott) to improve the match officials' scrum, line-out and maul knowledge.
  • URC Match Official Game Analyst is now full-time and will provide game footage to disciplinary processes, support Match Officials in-game reviews and match preparation. They will also collate match data relevant to the match official’s performance and game tendencies developing throughout the competition.

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For 14 free days, you can have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today. Thereafter you will be billed R75 per month. You can cancel anytime and if you cancel within 14 days you won't be billed. 
Subscribe to News24