‘My Tinder boyfriend is everything I wanted, but he’s broke’ – advice on choosing love over finances

  • Weekend stays in Airbnbs by the beach. Out. Nice dinner dates in the city. Deleted.
  • A local woman grapples with her dating downgrades – asking whether it’s worth staying with a man with no financial prospects. 
  • There are loads of women out there who are the so-called, ‘bread-winners’. Refinery29 even wrote an article about the conflicts involved in carrying this responsibility as a person. Not woman, but person.

What about a relationship where there is no breadwinner? My ex had a financial surplus close to payday. It was comfortable. Bread was won. But since we split, on my salary, it has been hard to justify luxuries. My financial menu is more set menu than buffet - slim-pickings in the options department. 

 After two years of being single, I had a nagging desire to invite someone, permanently, to my humble dining room table – so to speak. I extended the invite, matching with potential long-term dinner date companions on Tinder – and managed to catch a fish. Sadly, I forgot to add ‘Let’s go Dutch’ to my bio.

READ MORE: Tinder date sends woman list of ‘improvements’ to make after their disastrous first date

He has no money. Or medical insurance. Or financial prospects. But he is a sensitive, quirky-cool guy and our sense of humour is 100% on par. He’s my person.  

A 2018 study by sociologists Elizabeth E. Bruch and M. E. J. Newman, titled ‘Aspirational pursuit of mates in online dating markets’ found that women are way less likely to date ‘out of their league’, i.e. mates they deem more attractive, educated, and/or financially successful. Whereas men tend to shoot for the stars, trying their luck – i.e. particularly when it comes to looks. 

READ MORE: I went on 3 different dates with 3 different guys in 1 day - this is what I learnt

With this man, it’s his Tinder bio that sparked joy in me. I must be honest, reading ‘Business Owner’ below a handsome face, piqued interest.  But his business is micro, at best. He didn’t catfish me, but I do feel like a fish out of water.

I find myself making excuses for him. I work around our ‘situation’ to avoid shame or embarrassment. I suggest we do things that cost nothing with friends– we go to cheap bars where I ‘accidentally’ buy his round, and host dinner parties way more often than I used to - always at my expense. Is it worth paying for his poor management of finances? Quite literally. 

I think I would’ve deemed it so, had I been the breadwinner. But seeing that my current situation is more bread for dinner than a winner, winner chicken dinner; I’m negotiating outside my realm of control, here.

READ MORE: No need to dumb yourself down to find love - men prefer educated Tinderellas, study says

Psychologist Dr Giada Del Fabbro says, “…men who depend on them (women) financially may be seen as exploiting women’s new power when they are seen as traditionally capable of doing this themselves. 

“So, even though a woman can make her own money, she wants to be able to enjoy this rather than having it spoilt by a man who is seen as having a long history of being able of doing this himself and therefore lazy when he does not do so.”

This strain is problematic. I don’t want my friends and family to perceive him as a layabout. But why do I feel guilty that I expect him to be better, earn more, to take charge and take me on a date? We haven’t been on one yet.   

READ MORE: Tinder’s most ‘swiped right’ guy finally finds love – the old-fashioned way

“Men who are poor at managing their money or who want to depend on their woman for financial support are betraying a long-held perception around masculinity and are thereby seen as defunct or dysfunctional in some way…,” adds Dr Giada Del Fabbro. 

I find myself dreaming up new ways to up and add to my income to graduate myself to ‘bread-winner’ status. To sustain us, essentially. To justify ‘keeping him’. 

Considering the cost, it might be a case of me emotionally blackmailing myself to buy into this kind of defunct masculinity. One where I still, inevitably find myself compromising my own needs and end up caged, as it holds its power over me still. 

If you were in a similar situation would you chose love or financial security? Share your thoughts with us here.

Sign up for W24's newsletters so you don't miss out on any of our hot stories and giveaways.

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For only R75 per month, you have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today.
Subscribe to News24
Voting Booth
What are you most looking forward to buying this Black Friday?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Results
It looks like the pandemic is still far from over, so more loungewear
16% - 23 votes
The lockdown has made me want to invest more in homeware and furniture, so I'll be adding those to my Black Friday cart
26% - 37 votes
I'm going to use it to get a headstart on Christmas gifting
38% - 55 votes
Footwear is all about comfort this year, so definitely sneakers
13% - 19 votes
It's a good time to get discounted wigs and other beauty essentials
6% - 9 votes
Vote