OPINION | Mobility is essential in getting the economy back to work


The National Automobile Dealers' Association (NADA) empathises with the South African government and the enormous balancing act it must perform as it weighs up saving lives, protecting the health sector, and getting the economy back on its feet as the Covid-19 crisis develops.

Mark Dommisse, national chairperson of NADA, says: "NADA applauds and agrees with the risk-adjusted and phased approach to unlocking economic activity, and in this regard, urges government to consider the retail automotive sector as a key component in getting all sectors operational.

"For the economy to function efficiently, it relies on various forms of crucial mobility services, including the repair and maintenance of private and public transport, parts availability, and new vehicle supply. The motor industry plays a critical role in getting people, products and services to market.

"It is therefore imperative that dealerships be among the first businesses to commence work when lockdown restrictions are eased."

As soon as the go-ahead is given, new vehicle production facilities in South Africa will resume operations and will require channels in which to distribute the products they assemble. Limiting demand to export only is unnecessarily prejudicial to the factories - domestic consumption driven by the NADA members will surely help reduce the pain to OEMs and their factory workers. Interrupted supply into the local market will cause lost sales, which inevitably will lead to lost jobs.

2020 ford figo

2020 Ford Figo. Image: QuickPic

Investment stock

Jebb McIntosh, founder of Combined Motor Holdings, now Chief Executive Officer & Director at CMH Holdings has this to say: "Automotive retail has a massive investment in stock, with interest costs growing daily, salaries being paid to staff and lease payments to landlords. Under the lockdown, these costs remain and are draining cash resources of every dealership. 

"Every day this continues, means an increase in the number of dealerships that will never open their doors again, and a greater number of retrenchments at dealerships that do open. This will only add to the growing number of jobless people begging the government for support.

"Franchised dealerships are disciplined businesses, that are used to complying with protocols which are overseen by OEMs and other stakeholders. Strict safety protocols are in place and have been from day one, ensuring the safety of both staff and customers. Also, dealerships are self-standing properties with a limited number of people visiting daily."

READ: Lockdown claims 13 500 new Toyota vehicles in SA - Here's how they plan to mitigate further damage

At present, there are approximately 1600 franchise dealers in South Africa, employing 60 000 people directly. Taking the multiplier effect into account, this number increases to nearly one million people in the full automotive industry value chain.

The investment that these franchise dealers (groups and independents) have on the table in dealership facilities and working capital is well over R40-billion – equating to a massive contribution to the Fiscus. Retail operations account for 2.5% of the motor industry's 6.9% contribution to GDP and can make a significant contribution to jump-starting the economy.

Ford Ranger silverton plant

Ford production line. Image: Quickpic

Osman Arbee, CEO of Motus, notes: "We employ 15 000 people in South Africa. As a result, the safety of our people and customers will always come first. However, by returning to work on May 4, we will be best placed to save our businesses, jobs and help government reduce the need for further support packages. The motor business can effectively apply the new hygiene standards and "Social Distancing" which will support the low transmission of spreading the Corona Virus due to the nature of the business where there are no large gatherings. 

"Our high tax base is a strong contributor to the fiscus, and we will help kick-start other industries, including the OEM's, parts manufacturers, vehicle asset financing, other financial services and the workshops. We also have a vital role to play in supporting the mobility needs of any other business or industry that is allowed to recommence trading. Simply put; we represent a low risk and high return opportunity," concludes Arbee.

There is additional investment in training and qualifications generated out of formalised trade skills in dealerships such as technical, sales, finance and insurance, administration, and accounting. 

These represent fantastic opportunities for this 60 000-person skills pot to contribute towards rebuilding the SA economy and, more broadly, also feeds important other sectors such as non-franchise workshops, motor vehicle body repairers, parts retailers, and used car dealers.

The coronavirus pandemic has forced the automotive industry to press the pause button, and the situation is dire for the sector as thousands of dealerships are currently in lockdown. The consequence of this is causing a massive cash flow stoppage to the fiscus, compounded by the issue of around one million people being out of work.

volkswagen amarok canyon,v6,bakkie

2020 Volkswagen Amarok Canyon. Image: Wheels24 / Charlen Raymond

The importance of dealer network

"It is crucial that the dealer retail market swings into gear as soon as possible," says WesBank Motor CEO, Ghana Msibi. "Dealers are a critical enabler in the automotive value chain, and with current technologies, the financial industry can be largely digitised. We can execute almost all aspects of finance and insurance processes online. We can nearly completely eliminate the need for consumers to enter dealerships before the final delivery of vehicles.

"WesBank predicts that social distancing will be part of our lives for quite some time to come and expects more people will be leaning towards safer means of transportation in efforts to avoid being exposed to contagious illnesses."

From a safety perspective, dealerships can adapt quite quickly and efficiently to ensure that their environments are as safe as possible. Dealerships generally have low footfall and spacious facilities – both of which are decisive factors to consider in guaranteeing effective social distancing and mitigating the risk of virus transmission.

Appointment scheduling and access control measures, which were mostly in place before the crisis, can ensure that the total number of people within facilities at any given time is monitored and controlled. 

isuzu d-max,bakkie

2020 Isuzu D-Max. Image: QuickPic

Lockdown extention?

Graeme Watson, CEO of Super Group Automotive, says: "While we remain fully supportive of government initiatives with regards to COVID-19, franchise dealerships are well geared to institute and manage a wide range of safety measures and infection prevention protocol. This will not only support a phased start-up process for the economy but will also provide a vital support to motorists that will need to rely on private vehicle usage as opposed to public or shared transport solutions."

"In addition to this, our staff rely on a considerable element of incentive-based earnings and a further extended lockdown period will have a dramatic effect on their livelihoods and will no doubt result in significant redundancies. This, together with our large fixed overheads and cash consumption during a prolonged lockdown period, will materially affect the future viability of many of our dealerships and the retail motor industry as a whole."

Brynn Stephenson, CEO of Unitrans Automotive Group, says: "We have 6000 staff members at Unitrans, with the majority earning a significant portion of their salaries on commission-based structures. Earning a basic salary, if paid without any commission, is in no way a sufficient income. With no turnover in our dealerships, cash reserves will soon be depleted, resulting in the frightening prospect of an entire business restructure."  

Franchised dealers operate under a range of stringent Manufacturer standards and government regulations. They can be relied upon to do everything in their control to protect staff and customers from the spread of infectious disease. 

NADA has a clear plan to drive adherence to safety and hygiene standards through ongoing research and consultation with the health sector. These standards will be enforced through communication campaigns, including consistent engagement with its members.

Dommisse concludes: "We remain committed to contributing and supporting the resurgence of the South African economy within the important safety constraints required to combat the Covid-19 pandemic.It is a sector of the economy that can contribute enormous benefit in the immediate-term, a factor that needs to be seriously considered by the government. 

"We are a highly vulnerable industry. Motor retail is right on the edge but, if it is saved, and can open quickly, we can bring in revenue both for dealership staff and to the fiscus, which is a win-win for all."

Disclaimer: Wheels24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of contributors/columnists published on Wheels24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24 or Wheels24. 

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For only R75 per month, you have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today.
Subscribe to News24
Lockdown For
Brought to you by
Voting Booth
Who do you feel was at fault for Verstappen and Hamilton's Italian GP crash?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
25% - 1453 votes
43% - 2473 votes
They were both at fault
32% - 1813 votes