OPINION | The new Ineos Grenadier SUV looks like the Defender Land Rover should have built

accreditation
All-new Ineos Grenadier (Ineos Media)
All-new Ineos Grenadier (Ineos Media)

• Wheels24 reader Guy Boardman has owned several 4x4 vehicles in his life.
• He shares his views on the Ineos Grenadier and the new Land Rover Defender. 
• Boardman doesn't think the Grenadier will do as well as the old 'Landies'.
For more motoring stories, go to Wheels24.



In my lifetime, as a 67-year-old 4x4 enthusiast, I think my opinion has some merit on the Ineos Grenadier and the Land Rover Defender.  

Since my university days and through the years, I have owned the following vehicles to justify my thoughts to follow: 
• 2 Land Rovers Series 2 (1979-1982) and a series 2a. (1973-1980)
• Toyota Hi-Lux 4x4 bakkie, the first model to come to South Africa. (1982- 1989)
• Land Cruiser FJ43 (1992-2008)
• Land Cruiser 80 Series Station Wagon1HZ diesel motor (2008 -2015)
• Suzuki Jimny (2014-2015)
• Suzuki Grand Vitara - (2015- to date)

The Grenadier looks like the Defender Land Rover should have built, not the current "thing" that they have thrust on the market that doesn't even resemble the Icon that the Land Rover Defender once was. 

Land Rover Defender,ineos grenadier
Ineos Grenadier (right) and Land Rover Defender (Wheels24)

Does Land Rover really believe they will gain market acceptance from the buying public for a vehicle that does not even look like an icon? It also comes in 37 different variants, three different engines, and the most affordable Land Rover comes in at over R1-million. The top of the range Defender costing R1.7 million for a 2.0-litre motor developing 297kW at 5500rpm and 640Nm of torque through some complicated hybrid electric drive. 

They have completely lost contact with the real world of 4x4, especially when comparing the Defender with the Discovery, the Range Rover Sport, and the Evoque. The only reason they could have done this is that they will drop some of those other ridiculous names like the Evoque and then maybe the Discovery as well. But enough about Land Rover. The real Land Rover Defender died when they fitted BMW engines and some of the German automaker's crazy technology.

With the Grenadier, Ineos has also gone to BMW for their engines when they should have gone to Toyota.

Ineos have their concepts right, but maybe some of their choices wrong:

 • A wheel at each corner: it creates space in between, and approach and exit angles are always better.
 • A ladder frame chassis: it simplifies construction and repair, and maintenance. 
 • A solid front and rear beam axles, because independent suspension can allow an engine or gearbox to bottom out when  braking on harsh terrain, and do not do too well when climbing rocks.
 • A big six motor because that generally produces enough torque, but BMW? No, thank you.
All the speed, all the power but no reliability; IMHO they would have done better with a Toyota 1HZ donkey cart engine. Makes you think why Toyota has never dropped its 1HZ. Reliability, absolutely essential that is what has made Toyota the world's leading brand.
 • Easy to work on/repair, because that is what 4x4 people are and what they do: they do things themselves and sometimes HAVE to do things themselves when they invariably run into a problem in the bush. Where will you find a bush mechanic capable of repairing a BMW engine when driving through Africa? Obviously Ineos were probably also stuck with only certain engine choices and the BMW engine would have been the best available, since Toyota would certainly not be providing a direct market competitor with its own engine. 

guy boardman, 4x4,offroading
Wheels24 reader Guy Boardman welding a broken tie rod on a 4x4 excursion in 2009 up Baboons Pass with an emergency battery welding kit..

So there you have it. The die-hard Land Rover Defender fanatics will most likely migrate to the Ineos Grenadier, but when it fails because of BMW's hi-tech technology, the Defender lovers will turn their back on the Grenadier.  The price will be significant because if it does not beat the Toyota range of vehicles such as the 76 and 79 series, people will instead go with the devil they know than the one you don't.

Sadly there are enough Land Rover jokes over the years for Toyota fans to not go for a Land Rover look-alike. So there is not much market opportunity there. The only market opportunity is the old Land Rover types - which for the same reason, I have ranted about the new Defender -  will never buy one as a replacement because the new Defender will never be able to replace the old Landie.

From my side, well I have sown my wild oats, done Baboon's Pass and I will pass quietly into that great night. So I will be staying with my Suzuki Grand Vitara, but damn if it had not been because of circumstances, basically ending in a wheelchair for two years, I should have never traded that Jimny for the GV.

As one of the Land Cruiser Club members said when I announced my choice of 4x4 for retirement: If you can pack enough food and camping goodies in a backpack for a one-week hike, how much more can you get into a Jimny? Sadly, it was kind of full once the wheelchair was loaded in and there was only space for two litres of milk, and a loaf of bread afterwards.


Last word: the Grenadier should sell, but never in the quantities of those Land Rovers that had the Solihull badge on the back - those were still Land Rovers!

Disclaimer: Wheels24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of contributors, columnists or readers published on Wheels24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24 or Wheels24.


We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For 14 free days, you can have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today. Thereafter you will be billed R75 per month. You can cancel anytime and if you cancel within 14 days you won't be billed. 
Subscribe to News24
Lockdown For
DAYS
HRS
MINS
Brought to you by
Voting Booth
Petrol prices are almost at R30 per litre. What are you doing to help deal with monthly fuel bills?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Results
I've downgraded my vehicle.
10% - 82 votes
I've joined a lift club.
4% - 33 votes
Nothing I can do. I am struggling with costs.
62% - 493 votes
Working from home is a saving grace.
24% - 193 votes
Vote