Corruption that 'Works'

2015-02-18 05:28

I haven’t contributed in this forum/ blog for a while. Been just sitting there quietly in the corner; observing, sucking my thumb and licking my wounds. Wounds inflicted by our political and societal woes. But I thought let me breathe a little.

I never thought I would write an article with such a title: corruption that works – an oxymoron of note. But given the society we live in, given the state of our beloved South Africa, I find myself having to adopt the position of a spouse living and staying in a relationship with an unfaithful partner. In spite of her husband’s infidelities, she can still find it within herself to say, “He’s not perfect but at least he takes ‘good’ care of me”. To put it in a song, Joe Thomas had a song with the line “I used to think that pain was a part of happiness…”

With a tail between my legs, today I am the one who has to sit back and think, “Maybe I can still find happiness in the midst of this pain”. I find myself being the one who has to concede “Despite these stains and fading colours, maybe I can still appreciate the beautiful rainbow in this nation”.

We live in a society that is marred with corruption - from politicians, to business, to the ordinary citizen. We see it across racial lines, public and private sector, and across cultures; we see it across religious denominations and within charitable organisations; we see corruption in the church, among 'saints', even among corruption-watchdogs. It is from this backdrop that I found myself thinking, despite all the corruption, maybe things can still work. I ask myself, what if, in spite all the corruption we see around us, things still worked? It won’t necessarily make it right, but maybe just OK.

In our beloved South Africa, what makes corruption so prevalent and so in our face is not necessarily because there is too much of it, but more because things do not work. And because things do not work, we then raise our eyebrows and then learn that corruption is at the root of the dysfunctional state of affairs. But what if things ‘worked’?

  • What if Zuma was a great president - despite having spent R250 million in his own house? **as I gasp for air**
  • What if our politicians really worked and delivered services - despite driving fancy cars and spending R50,000 at Nandos?
  • What if Khumalo Trading, after getting the tender, actually went and built quality roads and bridges, and delivered on time – despite having been awarded the tender irregularly?
  • What if the DG’s son actually did a good job as the CFO of that institution - despite having gotten the job through nepotism?
  • What if the education system actually worked - despite all the political and labour-related shenanigans?
  • What if Eskom delivered stable power - despite any instances of corruption?
  • What if through BEE, corporates were actually introduced to prominent & credible business partners - despite how the legislation is frowned upon by others.
  • What if those appointed as AA/ EE candidates (and I’m not saying AA/ EE is corruption) actually brought in a fresh perspective to whatever jobs they were appointed to?

Ok, I may be misinterpreted on the last 2 points on BEE and AA – let me reiterate that I by no means infer that BEE and AA are corrupt, because they are not. My point is that those who are against the policy would be more receptive to it if it worked as effectively as it was intended. Ok, let's move on.

The question I’m trying to drive to is, what if things worked despite all the corruption or allegations thereof? Can we ever have corruption that works?

Apartheid was a very corrupt system - with political and economic institutions that favoured the minority to the detriment of the majority. But for its mandate at the time, the very corrupt and unfair system actually worked. Which is why it is difficult for those who were in that minority back then to honestly say they never benefitted from the system, because they did, one way or the other. So, as much as the system was corrupt, it worked. That is why it lasted for as long as it did. And that is why the after effects can still be seen even today.

I have no doubt that even during apartheid, there were a lot of corrupt politicians. There was lots of corruption in awarding government business. There was lots of nepotism when it came to filling key posts, be it in government or private sector. But hey, things worked (for that minority at least). Hendrik Verwoerd (and his successors) may not have built themselves a R250 million house from state coffers, but I reckon their individual comprehensive benefits under the system would rival this figure.

Post-apartheid, the new political regime introduced us, or rather was supposed to introduce us, to a new political and economic system that was inclusive (as opposed to exclusive and extractive). Despite this noble mandate, the system and the regime as a whole has been marred by corruption (or allegations thereof), nepotism, irregularities, etc. – just like the apartheid system was. But now, the difference here is that the corruption in this case is compromising the system as a whole, almost rendering it dysfunctional. Now we are raising questions and we want another change of regime.

You see, when things work, we are more likely to keep our heads down and go on with our business. But when things are not working, then we raise our eyes and start questioning – then corruption is exposed. Whenever I hear of service delivery protests, it's never because the communities are complaining of corruption or nepotism, but almost always because things are not working. Only then do they start to question key appointments and the awarding of contracts. But if things were working, the communities would most likely just keep on with their daily activities without asking questions.

To make another typical example: the corruption around the building of the 2010 stadiums in the country. Yes, the construction companies corruptly colluded to inflate prices - effectively stealing from the state (I’m sure one of these days Juju will show up at their AGM and demand that they pay back the money). But guess what, in spite of that element of corruption, they actually built the stadiums, according to specifications, on time and did a good job. If the stadiums had not been completed on time or they were already falling apart because of shoddy service, then we both know this would be more of an issue that it is now. But things worked, despite the corruption. I am most certain there is a countless number of such cases of corruption, but often they don't even surface when things work. `

Sometimes I wonder if our biggest problem as a society is corruption or incompetence or lack of patriotism or just no sense of good service at all; or a combination of the above.

I’d like to make an appeal that we make things work; we must work. Even the Good Book states clearly: whatever your hand finds to do, do it with all your might.

If you get appointed onto a Board of a public institution, even if it’s because you’re the Minister’s cousin, the least you can do is be an effective member of the Board and make a difference. If you get preference over other candidates and get hired into job (because of your race or gender or ‘who you know’), the least you can do is work hard and diligently in that job.

If you get voted as President of the country, no matter under what cloud, the least you can do is be a good president nonetheless. If you are elected to be a member of parliament, no matter how unfair and non-transparent the process, the least you can do is treat our parliament with dignity.

If you get awarded a tender to build low cost houses, even if it’s an irregularly awarded contract, the least you can do is actually deliver, on time, good quality houses (don’t rush off to buy a Range Rover before you’ve even started with the project).

If you get a multi-billion Rand contract to build a power station, no matter the kick-backs involved, the least you can do is actually build the power station and give the people reliable electricity supply on time and within budget.

That is what I call ‘Corruption that Works’.

Maybe worldwide all politicians, all governments and most corporates are corrupt in one way or the other. But, most do work nonetheless.

Let us also have things working, despite and in spite of the prevalent corruption.

X, checking out.

As I get back to ‘work’. And back to my corner.

Catch me on twitter @xolanik

News24 Voices Terms & Conditions.


AB praises selfless skipper

2010-11-21 18:15

Join the conversation! encourages commentary submitted via MyNews24. Contributions of 200 words or more will be considered for publication.

We reserve editorial discretion to decide what will be published.
Read our comments policy for guidelines on contributions.

Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.