Fear of Hamas will not bring peace in Israel-Palestine

2015-11-01 20:47

The Israeli government must replace fear with courage and negotiate with Hamas, writes Suraya Dadoo

The Israeli government sustains its occupation of Palestine with fear. Fear of the Palestinian ‘demographic threat’. Fear of Iran. Fear of ISIS.  This siege mentality - so reminiscent of the tactics employed by the South African Apartheid regime to sow fear into the white population - manifested itself most clearly during the ANC’s recent hosting of Hamas’s political leadership in South Africa.

Israel’s response to the Khaled Misha'al-led Hamas delegation in South Africa was swift and predictable. Misha’al had barely entered Luthuli House when the head of the Africa branch of Israel’s Foreign Ministry, Yoram Elron, “reprimanded” South Africa’s deputy ambassador in Israel, calling the Hamas visit “an unfriendly act” by South Africa. According to Haaretz, the Israeli ambassador to South Africa, Arthur Lenk, intends submitting an official protest to the South African government.

The SAZF then issued a statement claiming that the values, aims and strategies of Hamas are opposed to the ANC.  The South African Jewish Board of Deputies (SAJBD) promised to expose Hamas’s “true” identity to the ANC.

It is puzzling why local pro-Israel organisations were outraged, given the obvious similarities between the two movements: both were formed as responses to political repression, and both adopted as their goal the complete liberation of their people and land through a comprehensive struggle – including, but not limited to, armed resistance. The shared history between the two movements is quite plain to see. Throughout the recent four-day visit to South Africa,  Misha’al repeatedly referenced the 1976 Soweto uprising as an inspiration for the first Palestinian intifada in 1987, and the founding of Hamas during that turbulent period. ANC veterans, in turn, fondly recalled training with Palestinian freedom-fighters in the then Soviet Union. It is bitterly ironic that organisations like the SAJBD and SAZF, who enjoyed a cosy relationship with the Apartheid regime, and helped demonise the ANC, now paint it as heroic and moral. In fact, in 1993, the then-president of the SAZF, Julius Weinstein, warned:

“In the new South Africa, it will be a different ball game: our friends will be in the minority and our enemies in the majority.”

The “enemies” Weinstein was referring to were the African National Congress (ANC) and other liberation movements that would shortly come to power.

Taken straight out of the swart gevaar handbook, various statements denouncing the Hamas presence in South Africa issued by the SAZF, SAJBD, the Freedom Front Plus, as well as the US-based Anti-Defamation League (ADL) all featured the word “terrorist”, and described how Hamas was - according to its Charter - sworn to the destruction of the Jewish state, and completely opposed to negotiations. So desperate was the SAZF, that it even tried (unsuccessfully) to place a full-page advert in the Sunday Times, warning South Africa about the “jihadist” Hamas.

The Hamas Charter The statements were ridiculous when it was plain to see that Hamas had clearly moved away from its 1988 Charter. Throughout the four-day visit to South Africa, Misha’al spoke at length about an independent Palestinian state in the West Bank, Jerusalem and Gaza, based on 1967 borders, with the Right of Return for Palestinian refugees. Hamas had committed itself to a just political solution – not merely a “two-state solution” where a Palestinian ‘mini-state’ has its major cities cut off from each other, its government unable to control its own water resources, develop its agriculture, or manage its trade with neighbouring states. In a joint statement, Mary Kluk and Ben Swartz of the SAZF and SAJBD again invoked the Hamas Charter, claiming that “the core ideology of Hamas is underpinned by a rabid hatred of the Jewish people.” Yet, on the day the statement was issued, Misha’al was scheduled to meet progressive Jewish groups in Johannesburg.

“The problem is not Judaism or Jews, it is the occupation,” Misha’al said repeatedly during interviews.

According to Misha’al, the Hamas Charter is no longer a true expression of the movement’s overall vision, and does not reflect the current thinking of the movement. Hamas does not even use the Charter on its website and uses its election manifesto, and more recent documents, to describe its overall vision and objectives.  For Israel’s apologists, however, Hamas has not gone far enough, and they demand that the movement formally abrogates the Charter.

The Charter of Israel’s ruling Likud Party “flatly rejects the establishment of a Palestinian Arab state west of the Jordan River [in the West Bank].” Defenders of Israel will say that this is just an “old” statement of principles not reflective of the Party’s actions in power. Has Likud been asked to formally distance itself from its Charter that calls for the destruction of a Palestinian state?

Should the ANC formally distance itself from the Freedom Charter, because some South Africans can argue that the Charter no longer represents the policy and values of today’s ANC? The doors of learning have not been opened to all. The land has not been shared among those who work it. The Right to Resist Misha’al has maintained, however, that Hamas will continue to resist occupation by all available means, including armed struggle - an inalienable right enshrined in the United Nations General Assembly resolutions, the Fourth Geneva Convention and its subsequent protocols.

“Where there is occupation and oppression there is resistance. Resistance is a duty,” declared Misha’al in South Africa.
The American Revolution, the French Revolution and Africa’s wars of liberation in the 1950’s and 1960’s confirm Misha’al’s statement. We honour Nelson Mandela as a hero because of his resistance to, not because of his subservience to, apartheid repression. The Warsaw Ghetto uprising by the Jewish population against Nazi occupiers, is a source of inspiration. Jews who joined the armed resistance in Poland, and other places under Nazi occupation, are heroes, not just for Jewish people - but for all of humanity, including Palestinian freedom-fighters. Arguing that the values, aims and strategies of Hamas are opposed to the ANC is scurrilous, and sanitises our bloody path to liberation. Israel’s defenders sell the South African, particularly Mandela’s, narrative as only one of reconciliation.
Have we forgotten that Mandela refused PW Botha’s offer of an early release if he renounced the armed struggle? Or that Mandela defiantly declared on the day he was released from prison that “until Apartheid has been dismantled, there is no reason why we should consider suspending the armed struggle.”

We are proud of the reconciliation dimension to our story. But for Palestinians, the essential narrative that South Africa has to offer is one of solidarity, reconciliation and resistance.

As South Africans we know too well that, viewed through a lens of fear, it is easy to dismiss a group as terrorists, sworn to violence and destruction. According to this narrative, they are undeserving of a seat at a negotiating table. Through internal resistance and international boycott,  the “terrorists” in South Africa found a seat at the table and had a stake in ensuring a lasting peace. Those who claim to care about Israel, will encourage the Israeli government to replace fear with courage, so that this can happen for Palestinians and Israelis too.

Suraya Dadoo is a researcher for Media Review Network, a Johannesburg-based advocacy group. She is also the co-author of Why Israel? The Anatomy of Zionist Apartheid: A South African Perspective (Porcupine Press, 2013). Find her on Twitter: @Suraya_Dadoo

See also: Hamas: We Draw Inspiration from Mandela and the ANC: An Exclusive Interview with Usamah Hamdan

News24 Voices Terms & Conditions.


AB praises selfless skipper

2010-11-21 18:15

Join the conversation!

24.com encourages commentary submitted via MyNews24. Contributions of 200 words or more will be considered for publication.

We reserve editorial discretion to decide what will be published.
Read our comments policy for guidelines on contributions.

Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.